Wow, this thread really exploded today. Thanks everyone for the input and questions, and apologies in advance for the messy multi-quote to follow.
Usually I gig with either the Walkabout (in the combo or on top of the Genz cab, but never at the same time) or an old 800RB. At some point I'll likely sell the WA in its combo and move to a different amp. I love the WA and have for a long time, but the music I'm playing lately wants something with a little more attack and immediacy. To be honest, I figure I'll deal with the head situation later, because currently I get a good portion of my sound from pedal preamps.
You're right, the Scout cab isn't really great, especially for what I want it to do. It's fantastic on low volume blues gigs, but I'm shifting towards a scenario where I want more beef and aggression, not just warmth. As for the reason I'm swapping out the 212 as well- the goal here is to have one relatively consistent tone whether I'm at a low volume with one cab or a high volume with two- hence getting two matching, smallish cabs.
My plan is definitely to get two of a kind from somewhere, but I want to know what people hold in high regard so I can start my search somewhere. Finding out everyone's favorite company is half the fun!
Bergantino, noted. I've seen a lot of guys say great things but I don't know that I've ever heard one in person. Is there a specific line I should be paying attention to?
I hadn't heard of these guys before and they're definitely intriguing- the "super cab" claims are always dubious to me but I'm eager to find out more especially if they're local(ish) to my neck of the woods.
Barefaced seems super interesting to me but I'm a little hesitant being that they're on the wrong side of the pond and p*litics is what it is right now. I do love their cosmetics and the form factor is cool- maybe it's worth keeping an eye out in the classifieds or something.
Bag End has always seemed so classy to me- I remember being a kid and seeing those deep red cabinets and loving the sound they produced. But I've also heard that they're pretty mid-present and might not do super well with low tunings or fivers. They'd probably be on my short list if I were still doing more Americana type stuff primarily.
The GK Neo stuff was already VERY high on my list, but it's interesting that both of you are using a pair of 12s and don't quite agree on whether a single cab would be enough for some gigs. I'd probably be looking for something a little more robust than 2x 112s for the sake of volume- I had a pair of the Series II Neo 112s about 10 years back and they didn't quite cut it in that department. The voicing was nice but there was a slight lack of true low end as well. Are the Series IV that much of an upgrade from the IIs?
I tried to love the Rumble stuff. I really did. They're light and loud and reliable and they look sharp and they're basically everywhere, but unfortunately the sound never really clicked for me.
Great suggestion. The Bass Array stuff is pretty wild. I'll have to do some digging.
I like Markbass stuff for the size-to-volume ratio, but I've had limited experience with them outside of backline type stuff (and one cheap BL combo I had for about 6 months). I always associate it with sort of warm, nasal, funky tones. But you put that beautiful Lakie in front of it... I'll buy WHATEVER you're selling.
GR cabs have intrigued me for a while, but I'm a little wary of paying a premium for lightness, no matter how cool the tech is. Feels like I can get a little more bang for my buck while I'm 30 and my back is still healthy.
I feel like you might have my aim backwards here- right now I feel like I have several separate rigs for different (volume) uses, and my hope in going modular is to have one sound I really love come to all my gigs with me. Plus, we're bass players. GAS is in our DNA.