+100
I'm an old analog guy.. mostly because that was what my my experience and exposure was.
When digital first started appearing - eg:Yammy 01v96 - the price was out of the budget for the average weekend warrior and I found the "layers" to be a challenge - coming from analog.
Move on a few years and digital started becoming more mainstream in the weekend warrior mkt - first with Presonus, then X32, and QSC, A&H, Soundcraft and others followed suit in the small footprint world.
Having been exposed to (and used) Presonus, Yamaha, Behringer, A&H and Soundcraft "digital" mixers, I WILL absolutely CHOOSE them over analog now!
Reliability is not an issue. Complete console settings backups (I can take my settings from one console and load to another in seconds), remote control, routing, matrix mixes, remote IEM mixing, ease of use, etc.. are all things that CAN be done with analog, but not at the price point digital provides.
Our current rig is basically power up and go. Three wireless IEM mixes (Senn G3's), one P16M (Aviom style) for drummer and one wedge mix for the BL, and the X32, all housed in one rack.
Can you tell I'm a convert ?? LOL
Analog is good. It's relatively cheap today, but the form factor and technology advances dictate that at some point, analog will probably go the way of the dinosaurs!