Their second album sucked, and then Shannon Hoon died.
Soup sucked? I normally agree with you, sir, but no no no no no!
No!
[Insert disclaimer about tastes being subjective, and all that ... ]
That first one starts out strong, sure, and "Dear Ol' Dad" is still their career high point as far as I'm concerned, but "Change" and "Holyman" are craptastic, false-deep-thought-teenage-sentiment junk. At least the one crappy track from
Soup ("Skinned") is a bona fide goof.
Soup is the sound of a band that was teetering on the jammy-hippie thing toppling over into a darker, more raw corner of the room. It's mature and still maintains the excellent and inventive musicianship of the first one.
And Soup has that "Toes Across the Floor" bassline ...
Not to mention the overall sound of the album--I personally hate what the Parashar brothers did to the first album (and to Pearl Jam's
Ten, but that's another topic). Again,
Soup sounds more raw and urgent (things I like).
Blind Melon has a sheen on it that needs to be sanded off for that album to be superior.
You and me, JimmyM, Blind Melon-off! Meet you in the schoolyard.