• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Affordable Stingray-style bass showdown!

Which would you pick and why?


  • Total voters
    94
Not to disrupt this thread, but the Ibanez ATK models do a damn good imitation of the EBMM Stringray. The pickups don't look the same. The sound is quite similar.
Ach! You beat me by 12 minutes.
14E5E628-3359-4356-AEF1-83B99E4A14FB.jpeg

Putting my money where my mouth is—but two for less than the money for a single EBMM!
 
Ach! You beat me by 12 minutes.
View attachment 3503172
Putting my money where my mouth is—but two for less than the money for a single EBMM!

Very nice. My ATK was built in 2006... bought in 2008. I had the fretless version with rosewood fingerboard and white fret lines, in the late 90's... purchased from a local guitar shop. I was an idiot and sold it on eBay and I regret it ever since. The black ATKs look cool as hell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Monterey Bay-ss
Very nice. My ATK was built in 2006... bought in 2008. I had the fretless version with rosewood fingerboard and white fret lines, in the late 90's... purchased from a local guitar shop. I was an idiot and sold it on eBay and I regret it ever since. The black ATKs look cool as hell.
Thanks! Bought the 5 new when they first came out in 1995; bought a 4 of about the same vintage a few months ago. Again, seriously worth considering if you’re a fan of the Stingray sound but not the Stingray price.
 
I've never played an OLP anything (bass or guitar) that ever felt or sounded good. I voted Sterling, I've never owned one but I've played a few and they were solid for the price.

If it's the tone you're looking for there are other companies making similar basses. Outside of SX and others making copies, you might check out G&L Kiloton or L1500. The tribute series is well made and affordable. The Warwick FNA is a cool bass with a SR vibe. Not as inexpensive as what you're looking at though.

As already pointed out if you hunt and be patient you can find deals on used US-made MM SRs (probably the best move if you really want one).
 
I have both a Sterling SB14 (I know, it's a Sterling import not a Stingray) and a SUB Ray. They are both great instruments. The Ray is actually modded with a US Stingray pau ferro unlined fretless neck, a Nordstrand 2B-3A preamp and Nordstrand MM 4.2 pickup. It's basically a step or two away from a US Ray but for a lot less money. Sounds great and touches on that Pino fretless sound.

The Sterling SB14 is stock but is very solid and versatile with its 3-way series/SC/parallel switch and 3-band eq. So yes, I think that the SBMM lines are great for the money and you can't go wrong.
 
Played a older passive OLP which was cheap at a pawn shop a while back. Played nicely & well finished but was well used. Didn’t get it, didn’t need it. Should have got it and put in a Nordy P pickup. Don’t want two basses though.
 
Ach! You beat me by 12 minutes.
View attachment 3503172
Putting my money where my mouth is—but two for less than the money for a single EBMM!

MY ATK. By the way, the ATK (with the old preamp) did things the modern Stingray couldnt do. I actually prefer it to MM's. Here is mine. If you ask, Ill tell u why.

20190525_160816.jpg

That SX looks amazing!
You should check the Retrovibe by Chowny EVO.

See mine above.
 

Attachments

  • 20190525_160816.jpg
    20190525_160816.jpg
    1,009.2 KB · Views: 26