One: choice of cabs matters a lot for the sound, especially when the brands are different. Your bass will sound different with an Ampeg cab compared to your Rumble cabs, for instance. So trying out another cab (the Ampeg PF115HE cab for example) will probably tell you a lot.
Two: I find (on the whole) the Fender Jazz Bass a good match with a 450 Hz boost and the Fender Precision Bass a good match with a 800 Hz boost.
IMHO YMMV
Hope this will help you a bit.
I really think you nailed it! I definitely preferred #2 when I was playing a Jazz Bass, and #3 when I was playing a P-Bass.
And when I needed to find a spot between the kick drum and the guitar and vocals, #1 always worked well for me.
IMO whomever developed the Ampeg’s 5-way selector switch and it’s EQ points was/is a genius, and is worthy of Sainthood.
For me, Ampeg’s Baxandall EQ is the best there is.