- Nov 24, 2008
- 4,343
- 7,163
- Disclosures
- Owner & designer, AudioKinesis; Auth. mfg, Big E (Home Audio only)
Eric prefers the Hathor slightly and I prefer the TC115 slightly, mostly a function of the low end. Eric prefers a smoother rolloff of the lower tuned hathor, and I feel for the gut punch of the higher tuning a little. Not a big deal.
In my opinion the upper mids/highs of the TC carried around the room just a little better, but I'm sure the Hathor was easier to hear on stage...
Anders' gig with rpsands was my first exposure to the Thunderchildren in person (I'd read HOURS worth of threads here before hearing it). My response was similar to what most everybody says.... WOW. Holy S*** that is full, clean LOUD bass.
To my ears the TC115 was the bigger presence of the two. I think rpsands is right, the Hathor is probably cleaner/clearer to the player's ear on stage, but from 25-50 ft back the low end of the TC115 was just breathtaking.
Thank you both very much! I appreciate the compare/contrast, and agree completely with your observations. The Thunderchild cabs are sort of a "known quantity", so your comparisons add to the body of information out there on the Hathor cab. Each does some things better, surprise surprise. I figure that's the way it ought to be.
After months of gigging my TC115 in a variety of acoustic situations (some very ugly and some very loud!) you can believe your ears. I love my TC112, and it does gigs a 12 shouldn't be able to do, but the TC115 doesn't break a sweat in '410 or 212 land'. Amazingly full, even, loud, nice sounding cab, and with Arnopol's composite build, it weighs about as much as the Epifani 112UL (back when the UL's were light)
Mike's composite builds take my TC115 and 212 cabs into new territory, as far as power-to-weight ratio goes.
* * * *
I've decided to leave the 8-ohm-only Thunderchild 118 project on the back burner for now at least. It's been developed, but I keep going back and forth on whether a 118 cab would find much acceptance in the marketplace.
In its place, I'm thinking of moving ahead with a 115 that could be offered in both 4 and 8 ohm variants. It would sort of sit in between the TC112 and TC115 Compact in size and weight (a bit closer to the TC115 Compact obviously), and performance. It would be based on the Faital 15PR400 woofer, the same one I'm using in the Hathor 1544, and would probably have the same horn section as the TC115. I'd probably dimension it more suitcase-like (shallow), in a move back towards the one-hand-portability of the TC112.
Also, the 1512 project (15" woofer + 12" guitar speaker) project will be undergoing some revisions. Beta-testing indicates that it's promising but not there yet. I still like the idea of a cab that really could be used for either guitar or bass, so I'm going to to keep working on it.
I'm also looking at ways to move into more affordable territory by going with ceramic magnets, hopefully without too much of a weight penalty.