TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I like the concept of covering all bases. Obviously the age old - "Insert freak player name here" could make a lump of wood with dental floss sound amazing is probably true. :

The bass(es) that fit me the best are the basses I'd want in my proverbial toolbox.
Thing is, I'm not entirely sure what those are.
I've never felt compelled as a player to bend myself to fit a particular brand or style of bass just because it's common. I'm more likely to get a good tone out of whatever it might be if it feels right in my hands, and that's what I seek in my instruments.

... My point is that gear doesn't make you a good player, playing does...


It might not make you a good player but a "better" player. Now, said gear doesn't have to be expensive but should fit your hands, body and style of play. Which will encourage one to play more comfortably and that leads to a better player![]()
I take objection to this concept of needing any particular bass. I see many people saying "well when you walk in a studio and engineer wants to see a . . . . . . and I can't get behind that. It's my belief that if you go in the studio and lay down a tasteful, solid groove, the bass will be irrelevant. If an engineer is thinking "I wish this dude had a P bass" then you aint rockin' that track. I don't have a problem talking about instruments, but this type of subject is so over done and pointless.
I think every bassist should have 3 types of bass instead of specific ones:
a vintage type (fender P, J, etc...)
a modern type (sadowsky, mtd, warwick, modulus, etc...)
a fretless
In my opinion, A Fender P (or copy), a Fender J (or copy), and a Music Man Stingray.
Agree? Disagree? Don't care?
Good list, but I'd have a T-Bird and some kinda fretless in there too
In regards to engineers, they only really ask for the typical basses as they are the industry standard. People have recorded with them for years and engineers know how to work them to get the best sound.
From an engineers perspective, it would be a major nightmare if everyone started bringing in basses that were not studio and record friendly.