• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bassists that 'Mess Up' Live

Status
Not open for further replies.
Have you ever seen a 'famous' bassist completely cock up on stage?

I know its easy for me to mess up live, but Im rather good at covering it up if it happens these days.

No one famous in particular comes to mind, but im wondering if there are any famous bassists out there with 'bad track records' at live gigs.
 
When I saw Primus a while back the whole show was perfect, except for when Les was playing the intro to Fish On. He hit what was obviously a very wrong note, and instead of just moving on and skipping the note he missed, he slid that wrong note all the way up the neck of his fretless, went "Whoops!" and then hit the right note and played the rest of the song.

I thought it was a great, humorous recovery to a bad bad mistake.
 
When I saw the Classic Yes concert in Chicago they had to start "America" three times to get in sync.

I seem to remember seeing Rush in the early 90s and Geddy sang the same verse twice during "Closer to the Heart".

If no one messed up, what would be the point of seeing them live?
 
I saw The Who in 1980 from the front row, Entwistle was right in front of me! At the first part of the concert, his right hand seemed a little stiff. He'd look back at Kenney Jones and smirk, it was so cool. About three songs into the show, he was warmed up and blazing! He looked so at ease onstage. It was one of the best concerts I've seen. :)
 
If you don't mess up live, you're not a bassist. You're a sequencer. ;)

Off the top of my head, I've seen Danny Lohner of NIN screw up a touch, but that's only because Trent Reznor was slamming into him at the time. :D Pete Steele of Type O Negative has hit some bad ones, but manages to turn them into beautiful feedback. Hell, even John Myung, who I'd classify as a "machine" hits the occasional clam.

The top story I've ever heard comes from Mike Keneally's bassist Bryan Beller, who writes about one of his first gigs with MK back on New Year's Eve of 1993. Reading about it, however, it's more than understandable;

"...Keneally was changing forms on the fly, extending sections that I thought had no business being extended, changing his part so much as to be unrecognizable—and differently every time. These guys were clearly operating at another level, and while they were as encouraging as they could be, I simply didn't know how to get there yet.

It showed in the performances. One was in a ballroom—the Catamaran, I believe—and the other was in this gigantic airplane hangar that was mostly empty. I tried my best to hang in there, but I was exposed on the simplest song: "The Car Song," of all things. The coda has a section where you groove in D minor for a certain number of bars before switching over to D major to take the song home. I was so focused on making sure that Toss didn't throw me off the beat—because he was ****ing with the meter like crazy—that I automatically switched tonalities at the same point as the recorded version. Well, I wasn't looking at or listening to Keneally, because if I had been, I'd have heard him clearly stay put in D Minor. I went to D major anyway, and wondered for nearly 20 bars why everything sounded so ****ed up. In what must have seemed like an eternity, Keneally waited for me to catch on and switch back to D minor before giving me the cue I should have been looking for all along. To make matters worse, it was the show closer.

Neither of us left that night feeling like any magic had occurred."
:help:

Yet over 10 years later, they've worked on over 15 "projects" (full-length albums, tribute album tracks, other people's albums, etc..) so it goes to show you.

A major screw-up on your first gig won't necessarily kill your chances at the gig. You might even make a career because/in spite of it. :D
 
FunkMachine said:
Have you ever seen a 'famous' bassist completely cock up on stage?
Since you're going by "Funk Machine"-
...from my readings, Jamerson was told to tone down his thing 'cause the road bassists for the various Motown acts were unable to pull off his lines. That may have been interesting to hear(though I kinda doubt the paying customers noticed anything different).
 
I've seen the former Incubus bassist totallly choke during a jam at one of their gigs,but it was weird because it was the singer who called out the jam suddenly and he just had to pull out a line quickly, the result was rather cheesy. :hmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.