TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
G&L SB-1
there isn't any one model that's the best. you have to go on an individual case by case basis because 2 of the exact same model could feel and sound different. that's how it is when you're dealing with mass produced stuff. with high end stuff like sadowsky, every instrument you play is going to be great. it's just a matter of preference what brand or model you buy. but with fender you could play a dozen duds from different price ranges before finding one that's pure magic. that's almost part of the fun, because when you find a good one you'll know you found something special.
The Selects also have quartersawn necks and compound radius fretboards, plus "select" pickups that really do sound great.
Never seen the need for a compound radius fretboard. And 1/4-sawn necks aren't really a huge selling feature on a multi-thousand dollar bass when the Modern Player Jazz Satin & Classic Series P both have one for considerably less.
Whatever. The OP was asking about best production P-Basses overall, and so I suggested he consider the Fender Select. My Select P is a very fine bass because of a combination of factors, including the neck, the exotic woods, the pickups and the weight.
There are other great P-Basses out there, too. Never said there weren't.
I am hoping that I can buy a Precision bass either later this summer or perhaps this fall. I've been contemplating it for some time and after thinking about it, I really would like to stick with Fender - perhaps somewhat out of tradition.
The thing is, I've played Sadowsky exclusively for a number of years now and all of the Fender American Standard Precisions I've tried have been really underwhelming - primarily because of quality of materials, fit\finish and playability. Sadowsky sets a really high bar in that regard, so the Fenders just feel down-market by comparison. Granted, I've played them all primarily at Guitar Center - so most have been horribly set up and in some cases beaten up a bit.
I did try a Custom Shop 59 last week and it was the first Precision Bass I really ever liked. I guess it is technically out of production now, but there are a few of them still available new out there. It is a good option and I may have bought that one if I had the funds available today. I also want to try the AVRI series, but not really sure the differences between them all and what would really suit me the best. I don't think I want to go any higher in price than the CS 59, unless there is a really compelling reason to do so.
Thoughts?
Tony Franklin Signature
Everyone of those I've played feels like a custom shop.