• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

best p-bass for under 300?

Used squier P's go for about $170 here. Rondo is out of anything 34" with a split coil P pickup until may. Guitar Fetish has a $200 Xavier Pbass. I like their pickups but have no experience with their instruments. I'd rather spend the money on a used Squier
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
View attachment 4166511 This was listed for $250 at my local music store. I talked them into a 10% discount and they gave me 60% of what they would list my Squier VM Fretless Jazz for as trade value. I walked out of there with this fantastic P-Bass for less than $50 with tax. Best P I’ve ever played.

It’s a 1986-1987 Ibanez Roadstar II RB630. I added TI Jazz Flats, Dunlop Straplocks and the chrome knobs from my Squier Jazz. Eventually I’ll get some new pickguard screws and maybe a new pickup. Until then it works great!

Fuji-Gen Gakki built
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
A lot boils down to the neck profile for me....i mean cmon P bass types are all over the entire planet so make sure the neck is what you want.

80's Peavey Fury have J necks while other P types may have more slender necks than Fender.

The other thing for me is weight....cant deal with over 8 lbs at all these days....other than that, parts can be changed easily on a P bass
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
A lot boils down to the neck profile for me....i mean cmon P bass types are all over the entire planet so make sure the neck is what you want.

80's Peavey Fury have J necks while other P types may have more slender necks than Fender.

The other thing for me is weight....cant deal with over 8 lbs at all these days....other than that, parts can be changed easily on a P bass
images.jpeg


SX P bass from Rondo Music, plays like a champ...

20201217_103431.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: StringslamDan
Harley Benton gear is highly under rated Imo! The stock pickups sound good, and being cheap, there'd be money left over to throw in an upgrade if you so desire, the necks are solid and they even come strung with Daddario xl's for around $120 dollars. I love my HB Jazz bass and will probably order a few more before its over!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Slater
Don't listen to this OP. A pickup shorted to ground on both sides won't produce a signal. When you turn the volume down, its output is zero. You could attach a billion grounded pickups to your bass and it would have absolutely no impact on the sound of the pickup that is on.

Edit: Well maybe not a billion - the billion parallel pots would short out the signal :)

Knowing anything about how signals work knows youre wrong.

But keep proving my point
 
  • Like
Reactions: StringslamDan
Knowing anything about how signals work knows youre wrong.

But keep proving my point

Not really following your logic here. But when you turn down a volume pot, both ends of the pickup are shorted together. By the most basic and fundamental rules in electronics, there will be ZERO voltage between the two ends of the pickup output (again, they are SHORTED TOGETHER). The only way this can then impact the output of the other pickup is the added resistance of the pot now in parallel with the other volume pot. This can affect the volume and will have no more impact on the tone than capacitor selection.

So as a correction, yes the second pickup can affect the volume and tone but only in the same way the capacitor value selection will affect tone (cut-off frequency). But you could connect a billion shorted out pickups to that ground node and you will not hear any change in the sound of the one pickup you have turned on. If you have evidence that you can develop a voltage across a shorted circuit node, I would love to see it. You'll probably get a Nobel Prize for the discovery.
 
Another thumbs up for the Yamaha BB234. It’s a PJ but using just the P pickup is the same sound as a P only bass. And you get a nice J scooped sound with both pickups full or a Jaco sound with the bridge pickup. I was a P or J purist but I now love the PJ. I did replace the pickups with EMG PJAX as the stock ones weren’t the best and had a lot of hum (I cured most of that with cavity shielding). I have a number of much more expensive basses but I’m playing the Yamaha much more than the others lately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skycruiser