Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Basses [BG]' started by philthygeezer, Jan 3, 2005.
Which will cover a broader range of music? Please discuss.
I happen to love both, they both fit into any style (I think the precision is more common) yet at the same time they're both fairly one trick ponies (but at the same time, they're not.. aah!) so really I've helped in no way and I will leave it up to the experts
Broader range of music? I agree with gord.
Quality? Stingray. Hands down. No question about it.
+1 and playability, look and just a little more options also if you choose the 3-band onboard EQ!
Stingray, but honestly, if you're looking for a broad range of tones, get something with 2 pickups in it.
P bass. Pup is versatile becasue you can open it up or make it dark and dubish. It is in the midde, as oppossed to riding the bridge.
Is there any gig that a P bass would NOT work in?
History has shown both basses to have been used in every music genre that requires a bass guitar so the answer is...tie score.
Play a few examples of both and pick the one you like better,
Both are great basses.
YOu can't go wrong with either.
Try both, and get the one you like best.
My vote is for the P bass simply because I used to own a 'Ray and I always had a hard time coaxing more then one tone ot of it. That one tone didn't work so well for all the types of music I play. It's pretty much the same thing w/ a P - there really isn't too much that can change w/ the tone of a P using the onboard controls - but the tones that I'm stuck w/ on a P work w/ everything
if you're looking at overall quality, i think the stingray is better. one thing i notice is it balances on a strap way better than the precision does. i also think it's a bit more versatile as far as what sounds you can get out of it. i agree with the others though. play both and see which one YOU like. that's the deciding factor for any bass.
I own both but I don't play the P much anymore. I really prefer the Stingray sound over the P bass sound.
I thought I liked the sound of the Stingray until I played one in a band. Its now one of the few basses I dont like the tone of. I really tried to like the sound but it just didnt happen. I have had better luck getting a precision to fit into different types of music. YMMV I guess I should say.
like said before, they both aren't very versatile, but they fit in any musical style.
But musicman wins with building quality, playability and sound I think
Definitely Jazz. Then MM, then P. Sonic possibilities are way more with the bridge pup, but the MM, if you're a finesse player, can get more tones than a P. A P sounds like a P to me- hollow, woody thump. Of course this is just MY opinion, YMMV.
everyone brought up good points, you really have to check it out for yourself. The P has a bigger neck I think, and fender quality control is definetally something to look out for. I've seen fenders that play amazingly and play horribly, directly beside eachother. Every MM I've tried has felt the same way, the feel is justified in the price definetally. I have a Stingray and Precision at home, they're totally different, and that's what I like about them. Lately I've noticed if you want versitility, you can't beat two pickups. I believe Fender put out a precision style bass with a stingray style humbuckler or soapbar (I forget the name) so that would be worth checking out, or a PJ, which is a very interesting choice, the jazz pickups up where the precision leaves off, it gives mid and highs, lacking in the lows but the precision levels that off nicely. If I were you I'd try a precision, a stingray, and then anything with a P/J combo. Also, I've found a gibson or epiphone (oddly, I like epiphone better) thunderbird, it gives the stingray growl but the precision deepness, but that's just me
What??? another P-bass vs Stingray thread??
I chose Both!!!
You are probably thinking of the American Deluxe Precision Bass®. I recently asked if anyone had compared the bridge pickup on this with the 'Ray but seemingly no one had.
I would, if I were me, take the Stingray.
Now, let me think about what I would do if I were you.
This may take a while.
A contradiction? I agree that each will fit into any style (that you happen to find yourself playing them in.) They are therefore both versatile.
I ment that they both don't cover a lot of diffirent sounds