• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bo Bice

Um. I think I might have lost my man card. I'm just watched Bo Bice play one of his songs on American Idol. It was good. I am a true monkey. This has been an odd day indeed.

Quoted! Just for the sake of historical accuracy :D

I actually thought that the grey haired guy from last year did a great job of singing the National Anthem at the Sprint Cup Race last weekend.............Errr............ That was the first time I ever heard him and it was before a RACE :ninja: I can't even remember his name :confused:
 
Quoted! Just for the sake of historical accuracy :D

I actually thought that the grey haired guy from last year did a great job of singing the National Anthem at the Sprint Cup Race last weekend.............Errr............ That was the first time I ever heard him and it was before a RACE :ninja: I can't even remember his name :confused:

Crap! You got it before I could delete. :atoz:
 
He has a good voice for southern rock. That said, he's a good example of the failings of a show like American Idol. Out of curiosity I took home an advance copy of his first album from a music writer friend when it first made the rounds for reviews. It was terrible. A reheated turd.

Trying to make a slickly produced, "modern rock" album with mass appeal was the complete antithesis of what should have been done with a guy like that. It just sanitizes away what appeal he does have. In a way it reminds me of when I went to see Gavin DeGraw years ago. Great show. Raw, soulful, even jazzy and funky in spots. When his actual album came out I was shocked at how everything I liked about that show had been scraped away in lieu of commercial schlock. I kept thinking, "this is the same guy?"

I told my buddy that what I saw happening with Bo Bice was that his album would sell initially but ultimately be viewed as a disappointment and interest in him would wane. Then when he had more freedom to make his kind of music, it would be a big improvement. I'm listening to his new album on Napster right now and that certainly seems to be the case. Still not really my kind of music (if I'm in the mood for new "southern rock" I like Kings of Leon) but it's the kind of album he should have been allowed to make the first time around.

For the record, I don't understand the appeal of American Idol, but it certainly seems to have some heroin like hold on a great many people that I previously considered rational, discriminating music listeners. In fact, two weeks ago my girlfriend got in a huff because I referred to it as a "karaoke show".
 
I saw it too Maki and liked it ok. Maybe it was just the fact that I had to sit through the breathy punk sing Elvis. Now that was horrible but the judges loved it. And like the BigO was talking about I remember when Hank Williams Jr was huge in the 80's and I saw him do 'The Man Of Steel" song before the album came out. He did it with only an acoustic guitar and it was sad and bluesy and very cool. Nothing at all like the song on the album which was pop country. I think Hank's downward slope began there. Now he is a sideman for Kid Rock.
 
i'd actually watch the show if there wasn't so much crap in between performances.
really, who likes those stupid dialogues or (heaven forbid) those schmaltzy commercials?

well, i don't, let me not speak for anyone else...