This is a wild thread for me. I used to use Carlsson's 20 years ago, but got a Nymans last November when I came back to the bass. Decided to also order a Carlsson's. They feel different to me. The Carlsson's feels softer and gunkier, and I don't like it. Climate is of course also a factor. I'm in central Maryland where it is humid all year and pretty warm for 7 months. I was searching on here to see what people had to say about the difference. It would never occur to me that they are the same thing when they feel so different on my bass. Oh well.