• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

cheap and lightweight for (direct) recording?

hey all, first thread. thanks for any replies!


direct recording:

i'm looking for a bass to record direct with, (through an Apogee One). aside from passive over active, any other general advice?


cheap, if possible:

i think you typically get what you pay for, and i could invest in a good bass, but for the moment, i'm considering a 'starter' bass. i am pretty serious about music, though, and have been playing for years now, including bass. (just don't have one now.) if you really think i should put in more $$$, i'm all ears.


size matters, or weight does, anyway:

after starting on some recording, my tele has proven to be somewhat of a burden. my back has been bothering me, though its not entirely the guitar's fault. i picked up a Duo Sonic (Squier guitar) at Best Buy a few days ago and the super light weight was absolutely heavenly. after that, i decided i should try and get something light for a bass, which in practice means i've been looking at short scale basses.


some contenders (including some cheaters): any other ideas?

Squier Bronco: $150, singe coil, Agathis, ? lbs
Squier VM Jaguar Short Scale: $170, P/J pickups, Agathis, ? lbs
Squier VM Mustang (New): $280, split single coil, Basswood, ? lbs
Gretsch Electromatic Jr: $250, humbucker, (wood?), ? lbs

also considering:
Danelectro Longhorn: $350
Squier CV Jazz: $350
Fender MIM Jazz: (weight and) cost aside, i would love a white Jazz! (if not now, eventually ...)
Fender MIJ Mustang


anyone have experience recording direct with these?

i guess weight can really fluctuate within a given model, but if you can report weights for these or your other suggestions, i would greatly appreciate it! it is virtually impossible to research weight! (i've read the threads. there is plenty of anecdotal data on something like the MIM Jazz, but with no mention of weight in spec sheets, the other basses are harder to pin down.)

THANKS!

**********************************************

EDIT: Thanks for your advice everyone!

I found a good deal on a used MIJ Mustang which should arrive this week. Aside from the weight, I like the feel of a short scale neck. (I like full scale too.) I figure the pickups are similar to the Precision's, so hopefully I'll get a decent sound without too much noise.

I'll update this when I get it and have recorded it.
 
A light Precision or at least "Precision-like" bass is the answer.

If it's too heavy, record sitting down.

The claim is that the Precision has been on more (direct) recordings than nearly everything else combined and that's true for numerous good technical reasons, not mere habit.

You can't lose. The Precision is THE recording bass.

There are many objections to some of the ones you have listed, but there's no point going into them.
 
Don't narrow yourself to just short scale. Warwick Corvette basses are very light. I had one that was only 7lbs. Also Spector ReBops are on the light side. But these are both a bit higher in cost so you would want to look for used.

I think the main thing is to get something that has no humm from the pickups since you will be doing direct recording.

EMG pickups have no humm