Pedals these days have gotten really good. Take something like the Ampeg SCR-DI for instance. Makes pretty much any amp sound like an Ampeg. Anyone ever try getting a random power amp, a good cab and running a pedal like this? Im thinking an older, used Peavey amp with a nice cab or two running the Ampeg pedal might sound pretty good on the cheap. Thoughts?
Yes, that's a viable solution. I've used an Eden WTDI at numerous locations where I was forced to use their backline. The WTDI is a DI box that has a built Eden preamp with adjustable compressor built in. I just plug that rascal into the effects-in/effects-return of the backline amp and it bypasses the amp's preamp and just uses their power section.
I've made Peavey, GK, Ampeg, and MarkBass amps all sound like my Eden amp. I bought this because I was required to use a little Peavey 112 combo at a small venue and I just couldn't get a sound I liked out of the Peavey. This little box made it sound like my Eden gear.
I also used it as a DI to the board on a recent recording session where the studio wanted me to run straight to the board. They preferred that I use their DI, but I used my WTDI instead. After the session the engineer came out to see what I was using that sounded so good - really recorded beautifully. His comment was, "Doesn't Eden want to sell amps anymore?"
So yeah, find a preamp in a DI that you like the sound of, get yourself a decent cabinet, and worry less about how a particular amp sounds. As long as it has the power you need, and you have a good cab to receive the signal that DI stompbox with built-in preamp is really all you need.
My WTDI has gain and master, Enhance (I never use this when playing in a group), adjustable compressor, Bass, Mids (toggles between 500Hz and 2KHz - I boost it slightly at 500Hz) and Treble. It's also works great directly into the board with FOH.
I paid $150 for my WTDI. Here's a shot of it: