Could be late, but..
I say go for it.
I also say.. isn't slang for stingray called a RAY?
I say go for it.
I also say.. isn't slang for stingray called a RAY?
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Considering downsizing to a P
- Thread starter ToneMonkey
- Start date
Do it. Simple, effective instrument. 2 knobs. No battery. Just straight and simple. Love my P.
Find a Classic series or a pre EB Ray, they've got gloss necks.
I'm not a flats guy at all, but I usually give them a shot every once in a while. I had my SR5 strung up with EB Cobalt flats, and man did it work! It sat in the mix beautifully, full and cutting all at the same time. I wanted to gig the bass but kept putting it off because flats on it. I went against my judgement and took it anyways and I was really happy that I did!
Just to offer a little counterpoint...
I think you meant to say upgrading to a p bass... please correct the title.
Thx!
Thx!
Absolutely go for it. Get behind a good P. I think you will be very pleased. If not, they are an easy sell or modification parts are are everywhere everyday.
It is a bit odd the way you present the situation. You are suggesting that ditching the Stingray for a Precision is a form of downsizing, as if the Precision was a lesser bass than the Stingray.
A Precision with flatwounds and a tort pickguard is a revered object in these parts!
A Precision with flatwounds and a tort pickguard is a revered object in these parts!
+1.....and i swear by those hipshot kickass bridges, got them installed on my J and P/J, their great!.....That being said i played a P for many years before i got into building and that bass was fine for everything imho
Love that Blue Wood grain; beautiful!
I have the USA P-Bass Elite, 2015, IDK if there's anything range-wise that I can't dial in...problem is, it's a lot of dialing! I'd almost rather have a 2nd or 3rd bass for different sound targets...but my wife disagrees! It is switched passive/active, J & P-Bass sounds for neck/bridge pick-ups, even has an EBMM growl to it.
But I love the new 2020 Classic Stingray's, admittedly for the aesthetics as much as the sound, just released this month, a lot of the issues described here have been resolved, though I wish they would get over themselves and incorporate a simple active/passive switch.
Similar here, but I use a Warwick $$ w/flats instead - fun to play, fast neck!
My only objection to that is that's the name used for the Sterling series, non-EBMM lower cost basses, e.g., "RAY 35". I say use it for those made in China/Indonesia, use Sting for 'merika
That's odd. What's the pickup/electronics/strings/etc? I've never had that problem. I've had and/or built about 8 P-Basses in the past few years and not one of them had that problem. I did notice that when I installed Bartolini's that it was a bit on the "mellow" side but still sounded good.
There's no such thing as "downsizing to a P." Sell all your basses, buy a P, and it would still be upsizing.
You're confusing mud with butter. Similar consistency but man... That P sound is like buttah!
Last edited:
Over the years I've used everything from EBO and EB2D to Tobias Growler 4. I've owned virtually everything at one time or another, but out of everything I've owned the one constant has been a P-Bass. Such a simple combination of a split pickup, volume and tone that was created over 50 years ago and still the top selling bass worldwide. There's a reason for that, versatility!
I still own a few of the basses from the past, but my Vintage ICON V4 (p-bass), Tele Bass (p-bass split pu) and my Mustang Bass are the ones I use nearly all the time. They never get lost in the mix and using Stellartone Tonestyler Bass 10s in all of them makes it a breeze to reproduce a particular sound or tone. You don't have to "chase" your tone control to locate a tone you had at the last gig. It's just a "click' away. I've been using them for quite a few years now and whenever I purchase a bass that's the first mod..
I still own a few of the basses from the past, but my Vintage ICON V4 (p-bass), Tele Bass (p-bass split pu) and my Mustang Bass are the ones I use nearly all the time. They never get lost in the mix and using Stellartone Tonestyler Bass 10s in all of them makes it a breeze to reproduce a particular sound or tone. You don't have to "chase" your tone control to locate a tone you had at the last gig. It's just a "click' away. I've been using them for quite a few years now and whenever I purchase a bass that's the first mod..
I understand what you mean by "downsizing"... Buying a P-bass is generally less expensive, weighs less, and is much simpler (no preamp, two knobs) compared to a Stingray.
I can't do the PJ thing either. Call me a purist but it always feels like the bass is having an identity crisis
. Not a fan of the sound of the pups blended and prefer the clean aesthetics of a pure P or pure J. The magic of a J comes to life from blending its pups and the P doesn't need any help.Sting Rays are fun to play but I haven't ever gotten along with them to the point of owning one mainly just because they don't fit in to the music I play any where near as well as P's and J's. I agree with your assessment that they like to have rounds on em and love to be bright and zingy. If I played slap bass in a funk band or punk rock with a pick I'd have a Ray.
