• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Could you survive?

with plenty of wildlife, a mild climate, a lake for fishing, and plenty of natural resources like fruit and trees.... definitely, it would actually be quite fun

I agree, but those resources never seem to exist all at the same time!! In Maine, I ate clams and fish for 3 days. That was great but with only beach peas and wild rose hips as veggies, it gets old, FAST!! Fishing can take a LOT of time. Taking game much larger that what you can eat in 1-2 days is a waste of time as well unless it's very cold. I honestly don't know how the native Indians here in Florida survived. There is plenty of easy fishing and wild food but living in this climate year round...... They must have been tough.
 
I also went through a survival camp. It was Project USE- Urban-Suburban Environments. Learned all kinds of stuff. Like don't try to walk in a swamp when you're a scrawny 14 year-old carrying the food pack. All cans, about 100lbs. worth... Luckily, they pulled me out of the muck when I stepped in a hole and went knee-deep in mud, with water over my head! :eek: They saw my hands. We built shelter, did all our own water sourcing, learned navigation and rock climbing, did a canoe trip on Cedar Creek at midnight, by sunrise, we were at Barnegat Light. Learned some trapping, ate what we caught, (cans were long gone by that point), learned to improvise a lot of things you take for granted. At the end, there was a 3-day "solo", where they dropped you off in the middle of the Pine Barrens and you had to find water, make shelter, and feed yourself for three days. Some went hungry, some went without shelter, and some were fairly thirsty when they came to pick us up. I was near a stream (water source), and there was a thicket that I claimed as my camp, no fires were allowed, hiked three miles to visit my neighbor the second day, he had water, but hadn't constructed shelter, and was very hungry...showed him a blueberry patch I had passed. It was a blast!
 
Watch Man vs. Wild. There's all the tips you need.

man vs. wild is the most ******** show ever. if you did the stoopid s@!& that guy does you would be so dead. the show isnt even real, he has been caught being transported to a hotel overnight instead of spending it where ever he was "stranded". also, he has an entire film crew with him.

i cant remember the name of it, but there is another disc. channel show that often airs about the same time as man vs. wild. this other show features a much more realistic approach to pretty much the same idea. this guy films it all himself, he is completely alone, and he doesnt promote doing the idiotic things that man vs. wild does.
 
It would tough, real tough, but I think I could do it for a while. I did a couple survival camps in boy scouts, winter and summer. I've spent a lot of time camping, but that doesn't count for much as I either had dried food (for hike-in sites) or a cooler full of ice and food (drive-in campgrounds).

I suspect that the people saying they would enjoy it or thrive on it really have no idea what it's like to be cold, wet, and hungry with nothing but wilderness around you.
 
I'm pretty decent at woodscraft so I think I could probably manage. Although my big weak spot would be identifying edible plants. I wish I could do that but I'm too lazy to make the effort to do it. Would I have a gun? That would make things a lot easier. Even just a .22 rifle would be great for shooting birds and small game.

bc
 
i cant remember the name of it, but there is another disc. channel show that often airs about the same time as man vs. wild. this other show features a much more realistic approach to pretty much the same idea. this guy films it all himself, he is completely alone, and he doesnt promote doing the idiotic things that man vs. wild does.

Survivorman. Excellent show, what "Man vs. Wild" wishes it really was. One guy, one camera, 7 days. Good stuff.

Oh, and "Alive", that was in the Andes, not the Arctic.