For the younger crowd especially, the 90s alt stuff seems to go over well.
Here's a set list from an A-list band that I filled in with in at one of the better clubs in a hip part of town. Crowd loved the material, and there were into it all night long. Lots of 90s Alt in there. Helped that the lead vocalist was absolutely killer.
1. OLD APARTMENT (Bare Naked Ladies)
2. MY OWN WORST ENEMY (Lit)
3. MIDDLE (Jimmy Eat World)
4. TROUBLEMAKER (Weezer)
5. HEY JEALOUSY (Gin Blossoms)
6. BOYS OF SUMMER (The Ataris version)
7. SHE (Green Day)
8. SUMMER OF 69 (Bryan Adams)
9. HARD TO HANDLE (Black Crows)
10. INSIDE OUT (Eve 6)
11. ALWYS SMTHG THR 2 RMD ME (Marvelous 3 version)
12. SANTERIA (Sublime)
13. I WANT YOU TO WANT ME (Cheap Trick)
14. SMALL THINGS (Blink 182)
15. ARE YOU GONNA BE MY GIRL? (Jett)
16. SWEET CHILD OMINE (Guns & Roses)
17. SHIPPING UP TO BOSTON (Drop Kick Murphys)
18. JESSES GIRL (Rick Springfield)
19. BLISTER IN THE SUN (Violent Femmes)
20. JOKER (Steve Miller Band)
1. SCOTTY DOESNT KNOW (Lustra)
2. HEY SOUL SISTER (Train Rocked Out Version)
3. HIT ME W/ YR BEST SHOT (Pat Benetar)
4. POUR SOME SUGAR ON ME (Def Leppard)
5. BRICK HOUSE .. (The Commodores)
6. ..PLY THT FKY MSIC (Wild Cherry)
7. 99 RED BALLOONS (Gold Finger Version)
8. KRYPTONITE (3 Doors Down)
9. IF YOU WANT ME TO (Weezer)
10. FLAGPOLE SITTA (Harvey Danger)
11. SEX ON FIRE (Kings of Leon)
12. FAITH . (George Michael Rocked out version)
13. ...WLK LIKE AN EGYPTIAN (The Bangles)
14. SWEET HOME AL (Lynrd Skynrd)
15. WHAT I GOT (Sublime)
16. FOOT LOOSE (Kenny Logins)
17. DAMNIT (Blink 182)
18. AMERICAN GIRL (Tom Petty Rocked w/ funky ending)
19. SHOOK ME ALL NIGHT LONG (AC/DC)
I've got 6 of that 39 on my set list. Good to know I'm on a similar track of an a-list band.
I scoured youtube for a cover version of Sweet Child o Mine whose vocals I could reproduce (I can improvise bass well, but vocals not so much) and finally found one I liked. So, I'm not allowed to listen to the Axl verion anymore and am on a strict diet of listening to this promo vid on which the guy arranged the vocals very nicely I must say: ELEVEN...The Ultimate 80's Party Band covers Sweet Child o Mine! - YouTube