Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Critique my band
- Thread starter Kimpini
- Start date
Not bad. How was this recorded? The instruments seem in the background while the vocals are right up front with zero effects.....
I usually don't listen or critique on these threads much because the styles of music most school-aged bands play is just not to my taste and so it's just not fair, but I listened this morning ... and I've gotta say... well done, very well done! Good feel, very entertainment/listening worthy, I actually listened to the entire song.
Loved the bass tone and the vocals, the only part that I thought was not as good as the performance as a whole was the guitar solo, which sounded like your guitarist was a little too worried about being recorded and took a safe way out but not in keeping with the confidence of the rest of the perfomance.
You have a good sound, I would stay and listen to.
Loved the bass tone and the vocals, the only part that I thought was not as good as the performance as a whole was the guitar solo, which sounded like your guitarist was a little too worried about being recorded and took a safe way out but not in keeping with the confidence of the rest of the perfomance.
You have a good sound, I would stay and listen to.
I usually don't listen or critique on these threads much because the styles of music most school-aged bands play is just not to my taste and so it's just not fair, but I listened this morning ... and I've gotta say... well done, very well done! Good feel, very entertainment/listening worthy, I actually listened to the entire song.
Loved the bass tone and the vocals, the only part that I thought was not as good as the performance as a whole was the guitar solo, which sounded like your guitarist was a little too worried about being recorded and took a safe way out but not in keeping with the confidence of the rest of the perfomance.
You have a good sound, I would stay and listen to.
My exact thoughts also ..... it is very rare that I listen to an entire recording submitted for opinions, even more rare that I respond.
Well done !
It was recorded live in the schools radio station, the singer sang straight through the mic that the DJ used.
Your drummer has no sense of feel. He is terrible.
The rest of you are quite good though, I was pleasantly surprised.
But I'm surprised no one has mentioned your drummer yet......
The rest of you are quite good though, I was pleasantly surprised.
But I'm surprised no one has mentioned your drummer yet......
Thanks for the feedback, I'll be sure to talk to him about it, didn't really notice it until you pointed it out to me...
I think the drumming is okay, the recording of the drums is a little rough to listen to, but it's a live sounding recording and it's hard to track drums. God that girl is amazing, perfect for this kind of music. It would be great to hear you guys in a pro studio where you might be able to relax some more, everything sounds a little tame overall but wow, excellent.
Yeah pretty good. Singer has a nice sweet voice. At first thought that the drummer wasn't so hot, but listening again he's not so bad. Overall good stuff.
