• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass DB beginner Qs: Rabbath + French bow

Responses like this create an environment where it doesn't seem safe to be curious or ask questions.

Are you processing my journey through your own experiences? Does trying new things make you anxious? I'm unsure of what you intended in your response. Were you seeking to silence or reassure?

I didn't position anything as wrong or right in my comment. When did I say being tall is a disadvantage? The teacher mentioned being petite in reference to bass. Classical and jazz technique are represented in 2 different forums on talkbass. Has no one asked about the implied difference present on this site? If most folks start with Simandl, should I never wonder why I'm starting with Rabbath. Why is learning something challenging "preposterous?"
I wouldn't begin to know where to begin processing your journey so I will leave that to you. However, about half the students I work with present with what is a clearly earnest desire to do everything the best they can from the start. Often they're very nervous because they're hoping to be famous and are worried that they aren't doing enough in pursuit of that goal. Typically they are not hostile when I give them the advice that I gave you, but it has happened before and, then as now, I ignore it and instead focus constructively on repeating the advice that I attempted to give you before.

Addressing your question; no, neither fear nor anxiety have played much of a role in my own experience with this instrument. I started a long time ago with a Simandl instructor, I loved that. Then I spent several years studying with a Rabbath teacher, I loved that too. They had me switching from French to German and back, huge fan of both. Stool, no stool, etc etc. I spent years playing nothing but jazz because Simandl was sqaure, then years playing nothing but classical repertoire because jazz was for philistines, then nothing but bluegrass or americana or whatever was paying at the time. Exploring the space of possibilities on this big ridiculous instrument has been one of the great joys of my life.

What I learned is that there's really nothing to worry about. I gave you the advice that I did because you (and everyone who has been chosen by this instrument) have become enchanted by what I believe to be the most ridiculous instrument that a person could decide to play, other than perhaps the piano. The piano is ridiculous because every night of your life as a working musician, you may be called upon to play an instrument you have never even seen before, much less played. In order to succeed, flexiblity will be required. Adherance to particulars will, therefore, become a liability. You may need to stretch. You will play many rented instruments.

Once you understand what the challenge is, it's easy to see that there is no single best path to follow toward the goal of learning this instrument. You are likely to take many routes that don't yield fruit and have to back up and possibly start over again. You are going to change instruments, bows, strings, postures, methods, etc ad nauseam. You cannot optimize this process by making the right choices the first time through because you can only learn whether these methods work for you by trying them. That includes physical choices like the size and shape of the instrument, the grip and length and weight of the bow, and all of that. So the time that you spend thinking "must I choose A or B" is better spent exploring both A and B. It's really worth it.

Anwyay with all sincerity, it is absolutely good that you care about what matters, and I wish you the best of luck on the journey.
 
Classical studies, Rabbath and a French bow are just fine with the right teacher. Arco and classical bass methods are still the best foundation for the instrument. Any serious jazz bass teacher will put a student through a classical method with the bow along with any other stylistic things.
In the abstract, Simandl is still more solid and proven and the German bow is easier in the beginning - especially if there is not a teacher involved yet.
Since you found a professional teacher using Rabbath and the French bow, I would just go with it.
 
I have lately seen more methods written for beginning string students as a group(all four of the bowed instruments). Some of these are better than others from a bass perspective but none are as good IMO as S and R. Some are more like the George Vance concept(which I like) some are more Suzuki- like, or actual Suzuki. When a student shows up with one of these I try to do as much as possible to maximize their usefulness but it isn't always easy. The bass is not like the others in many respects and corrections and explanations often have to be made , hopefully without totally confusing the student. Some of my favorite people are violinists but most of the time they are not good bass teachers. I have mentioned before and still believe that if a student has a pending ensemble commitment which is often the case the Simandl approach (there are other methods which copy it) is the best at teaching what is needed right away and Rabbath also has very useful info and concepts as the student progresses.
 
This is not an abstract musing on methods and bows. The OP found a teacher using a common bow and a proven method. The question is whether they should look for another teacher and the answer is no.
The only possible reason to consider looking for someone else is if they are super into a bassist that plays German bow and want to use that bassists aesthetics as a starting point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Depechionista
4) I'm quite a bit taller than the teacher. Is there anything that I should be aware of in terms of how our statures might affect the way we'd individually approach the instrument that I should ask her about?
It was the same situation for me and my primary teacher. He told me to look at photographs of bassists shaped more like me. I would do the same in your case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Depechionista

Latest posts