I think you should go with that, then. From a decision making perspective you have a strong lean in one direction.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Decision Paralysis - new short scale
- Thread starter OneNut
- Start date
The jmj is gone... that Talman is stupid good, it's darn close to a P under the mic & it has a tad extra dimed. You said looking for P sound .. very picky & that Ibby just does it.
Can you expand a bit on why you like it. I've been pondering getting one of these, but keep chasing other shiny objects.
Cheers. The name of this thread sums it up for me. I got decision paralysis bad.It is fairly light, simple, fit comfortably when sitting, has a 4 saddle bridge and was cheap. It's not the "shortest" of the short scales in my house (my Gretsch G2220 feels a bit shorter due to the bridge being closer to the end of the body). I enjoyed the little I played it, but it is currently my 14 year old's number 1. I'm still contemplating one, but I'm getting remarks about the other bass I just picked up. I too have shiny object issues.
If you want a pretty decent Mustang comparo, this is it. The stock Bronco sounds remarkable good, all things considered
They have the typical traits of Maple vs. Rosewood. I like them both very much.
Get a local woodworker to route a P pickup into the Stingray, have a blend know and a switch (for P only) and have yourself a P/MM shorty? Potentially this could be a very cheap option too...
I've considered that as well as moving the existing pickup but it sort of seems a waste of a nice bass to do that. Just because I don't find the tone to my liking at the moment doesn't mean some else would.
Give the Epiphone SG E1 a try if you haven’t yet. They’re really fun little basses!
View attachment 7055865
Always in stock at L&M. I think they’re on sale right now for Rocktober..?And you can find them pretty cheap used too.
Probably neck dive is what didn’t gel. Gibsons need a warning label. However I will say if you like the tone, the Epiphone Newport has it minus the neck dive.
But you seem locked in on the Mustang. I’d get the Squier Mustang and upgrade pickups. Or buy the templates online and make a body myself so I could have a “coffee table” mustang instead of painted. But probably buy.
If I may, I believe that Capsule Music currently has a used Reverend Wattplower in stock. It's a short scale, no bridge pickup, and might get you close to what you are looking for? Failing that, it might give you the idea of what a Reverend Sentenel is going to feel like/sound like as long as the neck profiles/electronic configurations are the same? I'd love it if someone in the thread with Reverend experience can chime in on the accuracy of this, because I've never played a Reverend before as I am also cursed to live in Toronto; a wasteland for bass choice).
It's not that I'm locked into the Mustang per se - it's just was it most readily available to try as a short scale. I'd prefer to hear, under my own fingers, the bass before I put money down on it and the Mustangs are the most readily available.
My local L&M - 2 P/J Mustangs + EB-1 + EB-3(?) + Bronco and recently got a 2229B. On the last big sale they had a Gibson Les Paul Junior Tribute - nice but the body was way too big. Cosmo had a JMJ (which has now sold), CV + Bronco last time I was in. Another shop has a CV + 4 Jackson concert minions.
There's no Reverend dealer in Toronto (as far as I can tell). The shop that lists Schecter has nothing in stock. Sire's are out of stock everywhere as well. If I wanted long scale, I'd be fine but shorties are a very rare beast.
I had hand surgery around 10 years ago and after that I had trouble playing my 34 so I started searching for a shorty. I almost pulled the trigger on a Mustang until my nephew, who had a Gretsch Jr Jet, mentioned that he wanted a 34 so I offered to trade my P-bass. I only did it as a favor to him and had low expectations but I love the Gretsch and have been playing it ever since.
The Gretch has single coils that are not reverse wound reverse polarity, so it won’t hum cancel like a jazz bass will. I’m saying this so potential buyers will expect hum.
I really like the Vintera II Mustang - probably my next bass. I love the JMJ but found that no two are the same. I'd love to try a short scale Serek! I never thought it would happen but I'm now only playing Hofners at gigs. I'm digging the short scale feel and sound and I'm getting less hand cramps at long gigs.
The quality of Reverend basses is exceptional (imho). I play Dub Kings and I love the tonal flexibility they offer.
I played a G2229B in the store and thought the tones were pretty solid. Wouldn't run the bridge by itself, but neck and neck + bridge were in my zone. The color on it is ... acceptable.
I just looked at the Gretsch website and a G2220 in Bristol Fog or Imperial Stain is pretty darn nice looking.
Serek is unfortunately out of budget at this moment, and the Hofner's just don't do it for me from the shape department.
Here's something else to think about. Have you considered a medium scale perhaps 32"?
I went from a 34" to a short scale 30" and even thought it was light, I had difficulty with "muscle memory" and was constantly missing notes and ended up looking at the neck frequently while playing.
So I tried a 32" scale and the transition was nearly flawless.
There are some 32" scale basses out there.
I went from a 34" to a short scale 30" and even thought it was light, I had difficulty with "muscle memory" and was constantly missing notes and ended up looking at the neck frequently while playing.
So I tried a 32" scale and the transition was nearly flawless.
There are some 32" scale basses out there.
Last edited:
