• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Devoting time to Geddy

Alvaro Martín Gómez A.;9853558 said:
I spent years trying to nail all the stuff in this video.

^^^^^^ I am not sure how long you have to practice to play like that but I don't think I have enough time left on the right side of the grass to get 'er done. Crazy.


Geddy is the reason I picked up a bass back in 1978 when I was 14. Honestly though, I know very few RUSH songs from start to finish. Back then no one wanted to play RUSH in bands and for sure no one wanted to hear RUSH in the clubs. They seem to be bigger now then back in the day. There is a reason they are sometimes referred to as the world's biggest cult band.
 
Geddy was also the reason I first picked up bass, oh so many years ago. It is interesting -- I find the older stuff much easier to play than some of the newer, finger-swiping stuff. He really made a total left turn in his technique ~ a decade ago, and I'm still working on figuring it out.

<sigh>
 
Geddy was also the reason I first picked up bass, oh so many years ago. It is interesting -- I find the older stuff much easier to play than some of the newer, finger-swiping stuff. He really made a total left turn in his technique ~ a decade ago, and I'm still working on figuring it out.

<sigh>

His flamenco thing is pretty wicked. I saw RUSH last in 2008, front row, right in front of Geddy. He is an intense player even with the flamenco thing.
 
I'm another one who started playing because of Rush. Unfortunately Geddy's style and my own, such as it is, are very different.

I find that his lines aren't that hard for the most part once you figure out the positioning/approach to them, there's usually a definite patern, but his technique and approach are so different from my own I sometimes have a hard time getting the right feel, and that's the key.
 
I can play Open Secrets, but it's not too Geddy like during the guitar solo.

As far as the intro, verse, chorus, and bridge (Finding no absolution...) part, I can play those.

Open Secrets has got to be one of my favorite Rush songs, all because of Geddy's playing on it. On my YouTube video I play the basic riffs Geddy uses, but on the guitar solo I'm not nailing his lines, I'm more into trying to play in his style. I don't want to just ape him, but incorporate what he does into my own style.

I really like Hold Your Fire. I'm thinking my next playalong video is giong to be High Water.
 
When I started playing bass ( 11 years ago ... man time fly so fast ). I learn every song of Californication, Blood Sugar Sex Magic and One Hot Minute. I have move on quite fast after that.

Some motown, some classical, too many jazz standart, few Dream Theater, Al Di Meola, Primus and Victor Wooten.

I would really like to learn some song by John Patitucci but they are a bit too much for me at this time.


So in all ... I think it is nice for a moment but you have to move on.
 
Wow, can't believe I missed this thread on learning Geddy's basslines.

I picked up a bass about 3 years ago, tried learning from books, found it boring, so I asked a friend who played guitar to jam on some stuff. He said 'let's try Rush!', and since it's one of my favorite bands I said Sure!

Little did I know how difficult Rush songs are. But...I dug in and learned a few (from tabs on the web), but found tab limiting, so I wrote all the songs in tab and music note form on staff paper.

Things floundered with that first guitard, but then I found a really good guitar player that knows a lot of Rush tunes, and then a drummer crazy enough to try learning Rush songs too. We now jam regularly about once a month and try to do a few new Rush songs each time.

Oh yeah, as if bass wasn't enough, I learned to play keyboards and pedals (and I have even sung a few songs). It's very challenging, but it's been very rewarding. At first it seemed like a mess trying to play and sing, but once I devoted some practice time to a few songs things fell into place.

I never tire of learning new Rush songs, although we concentrate mostly on their first 9 albums and the longer Prog songs. I love their arrangements and complexity. They really are a muscisian's band.

Now that I have some experience I'm also branching into other Prog bands, and learning Slap, and other styles of bass playing.