• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Did fretboard oil make my strings sound dead

hbarcat

Supporting Member
Aug 24, 2006
10,229
18,649
Rochelle, Illinois
I recently bought a used bass for real cheap because it badl1y needed some maintenance. I replaced the strings with new SS rounds, fixed a few things, did a setup and it now plays and sounds great.

But the rosewood fretboard desperately needed to be conditioned so I ordered a bottle of finishing oil from Stewmac.

When the oil arrived I applied it as I've always done in the past except that I was too lazy to remove the strings. They were only on the bass for about a week and I wasn't about to change them.

There is no doubt that the strings got doused with oil but I assumed this would be okay because I did a thorough job of wiping the oil off the strings and the fretboard with a dry cloth.

The next day I began a practice session as usual and my bass tone was horrible. There was almost no treble. Instead of the piano like "ding-ding-ding-ding" sound I expected, I heard something like "blorp, blorp, blorp, blorp".

I checked everything in my signal chain. Both pickups in my passive PJ set worked fine. Tone control worked. preamp/DI fine. Cables functioning perfectly. I even bypassed everything and plugged directly into the board. Same issue.

Tried a different bass with active EMG P. That fixed the problem. The rich, grindy tone I'm used to. So, something about that bass was killing my tone.

I was stumped and gave up playing for the evening.

Then, today at work, I was thinking about this and it occurred to me that maybe the small amount residual oil on the strings was killing the tone. Is that the right answer?

If so, I don't believe that just 24 hours is enough to actually ruin the strings and I should be able to take them off, clean them with windex or something, reinstall them and they'll be fine.

I'll be back in my studio tomorrow night so I can figure this out and I'd like to have some advice before I tackle this.

What say you, TalkBass?
 
I recently bought a used bass for real cheap because it badl1y needed some maintenance. I replaced the strings with new SS rounds, fixed a few things, did a setup and it now plays and sounds great.

But the rosewood fretboard desperately needed to be conditioned so I ordered a bottle of finishing oil from Stewmac.

When the oil arrived I applied it as I've always done in the past except that I was too lazy to remove the strings. They were only on the bass for about a week and I wasn't about to change them.

There is no doubt that the strings got doused with oil but I assumed this would be okay because I did a thorough job of wiping the oil off the strings and the fretboard with a dry cloth.

The next day I began a practice session as usual and my bass tone was horrible. There was almost no treble. Instead of the piano like "ding-ding-ding-ding" sound I expected, I heard something like "blorp, blorp, blorp, blorp".

I checked everything in my signal chain. Both pickups in my passive PJ set worked fine. Tone control worked. preamp/DI fine. Cables functioning perfectly. I even bypassed everything and plugged directly into the board. Same issue.

Tried a different bass with active EMG P. That fixed the problem. The rich, grindy tone I'm used to. So, something about that bass was killing my tone.

I was stumped and gave up playing for the evening.

Then, today at work, I was thinking about this and it occurred to me that maybe the small amount residual oil on the strings was killing the tone. Is that the right answer?

If so, I don't believe that just 24 hours is enough to actually ruin the strings and I should be able to take them off, clean them with windex or something, reinstall them and they'll be fine.

I'll be back in my studio tomorrow night so I can figure this out and I'd like to have some advice before I tackle this.

What say you, TalkBass?

The oils from your skin, your dead skin, and the dirt and grime that oils attract are what cause strings to "die". You accelerated the process by putting oil on your strings.

Your laziness cost you the price of a set of strings.