• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Do I need a refret?

If those frets are properly crowned and you are comfortable playing it, I'd say some day.

I'd be a bit concerned about intonation when playing near the nut unless the nut slots have been deepened to compensate for the low frets.
 
I have an old Fender with frets maybe 1mm high.

1 mm is .039" - the new frets I get on my Warmoth necks are .043" high - 1 mm is plenty of fret height, if they're dressed right. You could get by with half that if they've been dressed well.

The OP doesn't really have frets anymore - that thing needed new frets a LONG time ago.
 
It is hard to tell from pictures but it doesn’t look like there’s much left to those frets. If you do decide to refret it I believe 1970 would have been 1: a veneer fretboard (although I could be wrong on that) and, more importantly, 2: fretted from the side instead of the face of the board. If the frets were pushed in from the side make sure whoever is doing the work understands what that means for removing the existing frets with minimal damage to the board.

Curious as to how one would pull this off. I've seen pics of the "treadle" device used for fret installation.

Riis
 
Looks like someone got the bright idea to grind those frets down in the instrument’s past. They really don’t count as frets anymore - they’re more like decorative metal inlays at this point.

I’d personally have an experienced luthier handle a refret for this bass sooner that later. A really good refret won’t be inexpensive, but it will have a night and day effect on the sound and playability on this axe. If you don’t live in an area that has a first-class luthier or tech within reasonable driving distance, sending a bass out for work is not unusual.
Agree. I have never seen fret wear edge to edge! Someone ground them down. And to have almost 100% wear above the 7th fret?
 
Agree. I have never seen fret wear edge to edge! Someone ground them down. And to have almost 100% wear above the 7th fret?
We’ll they’ve certainly been levelled, which would bring them down to the height of the lowest fret wherever it happened to be on the fingerboard. It’s not outside the realm of possibility that this has been played hard with roundwounds and levelled several times (or just once drastically! :roflmao:)
 
Curious as to how one would pull this off. I've seen pics of the "treadle" device used for fret installation.

Riis


I can’t say I’ve done it but in one of Dan Earlewine’s books he describes driving the fret out the way it was installed. Apparently if you can get enough of the end started out you can grab it with pullers and slide it the rest of the way out. According to Dan, fender did that up to 1980 or 82.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zooberwerx
Yes

Take it to someone VERY good and get ready to invest a bit of money. This is not something you want to cheap out on.

A great fret job is the only real playable difference between “boutique” instruments and everything else.

Get a great refret and you will have an awesome bass for years to come.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obese Chess
looks like my '67 jazz before i got it refretted. i was starting to have playability issues so it seemed like the right thing to do. i spent a long time looking for the right person to do the work and i'm very happy with how it turned out.
 
Time To Refret - Here is why...
The surface of the fret should have enough material so you can have a crown. The crown is the high center of the fret that provides precise intonation. When you have a flat fret, there is no crown and there is no more material left on the existing fret to sculpt a new crown. It's time to gitter done!

BTW- strings being far away from the fingerboard is a separate issue. The truss rod needs to be adjusted and/or perhaps the neck needs to be shimmed. Any luthier qualified to do a re-fret job will assess what has to happen with the truss and neck angle.
 
Last edited:
Hi all. I'm in new terrain here but I'm sure many have been here before me. This is a 1970 P bass neck. No frets buzz but they do seem quite flat against the fretboard, requiring me to press down pretty hard in the upper 10 frets in particular. Based on these photos, do folks think I need a refret...

a) now
b) someday, but not now
View attachment 4506717 View attachment 4506718

Before I would refret it, I would want to know why the strings are that far away from the fingerboard. Did you adjust it that way so the strings don’t buzz or has it always been that way. From your picture it looks like your string height is more than twice of my PB. I’m not seeing a lot of fret wear. It may just need a truss Rod adjustment, a simple fix.