I tend to EQ mostly flat and use no effects pedals, but have to admit...I am in the process of building a bit of a pedal board as an experimental winter project.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Pedals are great to play with at home in your bedroom behind closed doors - the problem comes when you start running around in public doing them "better kept private" thingsI tend to EQ mostly flat and use no effects pedals, but have to admit...I am in the process of building a bit of a pedal board as an experimental winter project.
Truer words never spoken. There is nothing "pure" about amplified sound. Nothing at all.Can one of you BCA guys explain to me how magnets picking up a vibrating string, travelling through at least 6 feet of cable to an amplifier that contains hundreds of components that will all have an effect on your tone, then travelling to a speaker and cabinet that are going to have their own frequency response/roll off is the pure tone of your bass. All your knobs at noon on your amp isn't necessarily flat regardless of the fact that you think it is. Want the pure sound of your bass? Unplug it. Be smug about nobody hearing your boring tone.
Yah, but converting those passive electrons to solid state electrons before converting them to tube electrons filters out all the mojoPassive bass to all tube with a couple pedals in between is the exact same mojo except you also have the option to step on a couple pedals![]()
Sorry but we choose to ignore your realityCan one of you BCA guys explain to me how magnets picking up a vibrating string, travelling through at least 6 feet of cable to an amplifier that contains hundreds of components that will all have an effect on your tone, then travelling to a speaker and cabinet that are going to have their own frequency response/roll off is the pure tone of your bass. All your knobs at noon on your amp isn't necessarily flat regardless of the fact that you think it is. Want the pure sound of your bass? Unplug it. Be smug about nobody hearing your boring tone.
Sorry but we choose to ignore your reality.
Or play upright.Can one of you BCA guys explain to me how magnets picking up a vibrating string, travelling through at least 6 feet of cable to an amplifier that contains hundreds of components that will all have an effect on your tone, then travelling to a speaker and cabinet that are going to have their own frequency response/roll off is the pure tone of your bass. All your knobs at noon on your amp isn't necessarily flat regardless of the fact that you think it is. Want the pure sound of your bass? Unplug it. Be smug about nobody hearing your boring tone.
Yes, this is what annoys me about it...the clear tone of superiority in the posts from the bass-cord-amp crowd.Clearly. Look, do whatever you like but acting like you're better than people who have a different approach to something and high fiving each other over how cool it is to be closed minded isn't something that should make you proud. It makes me sad.
Yah, that's because you don't have one of them fantabulous cryogenic superconducting negative capacitance $5000 cables like us high-born puristsYes, this is what annoys me about it...the clear tone of superiority in the posts from the bass-cord-amp crowd.
Yes, this is what annoys me about it...the clear tone of superiority in the posts from the bass-cord-amp crowd.
Do we have to go through the entire thread and collect all the "holier than thou" posts into one place for you, bro?I don't recall one person saying they are better for not using effects? Why so defensive?
It's the "tone" in which we type that we don't use or want effects that offends? Huh?
Lots of great players use effects and sound great.
I don't use effects because I always think my sound is better without them. I don't care if other people use them. If they sound good it is good.
I've not heard of chefs bragging that they cook entirely without seasoning.
Here's one of my favorite live bass clips. Can anyone ID the various pedals in Tony's rig? I'm certain he would not sound the same here without them.
And anyone who says "pedals don't matter live" is mistaken, I recall an LA Band called Muse who used to KILL live and the bassist used all kinds of tasty effects that DOMINATED AND DEFINED their live sound.
I don't recall one person saying they are better for not using effects? Why so defensive?
It's the "tone" in which we type that we don't use or want effects that offends? Huh?
Lots of great players use effects and sound great.
I don't use effects because I always think my sound is better without them. I don't care if other people use them. If they sound good it is good.
No, just one would prove me wrong.Do we have to go through the entire thread and collect all the "holier than thou" posts into one place for you, bro?
I'm on page 3 so far. I have not seen a single example yet.Read the thread there's at least 4 or 5 examples of BCA superiority complex on every page. That's what is annoying. There are ways of saying you prefer your clean sound and don't use effects without sounding like a complete a$$hole. It might be hard for some people but it is possible.