Hey everyone! I'm in the market for a 5 string - first off I'm very much a P bass kinda guy and have been trying to figure out the best 5 string for me. I've been lurking on this thread for a while and became convinced the Special might be the one for me. I notice my local GC had a 5HH in stock so i went this morning to check it out and it was pretty much everything i hoped and am now convinced i need to get one. My question for ya'll is H vs HH and finger/thumb rest positioning. Being a P bass player mainly, I like where my thumb rests in the middle to upper middle closer to the neck. Playing the 5HH I naturally rested my thumb on the neck pickup and wasn't feeling the placement of the bridge pickup for finger style. So I'm kinda thinking I HAVE to get a 5HH. Can any one chime in on this?
Also I liked the tone in the center with both pickups, felt more balanced and beefy than just the traditional bridge pickup solo'd, maybe another reason I have to get a 5HH over 5H. Would appreciate any thoughts!
PS - i realized that i was seated and that it might feel different than standing with a strap. so maybe that would be something to consider...
I'd think that an HH would be more up your alley. As far as position 3, yes, it's very meaty and fat. I wanted to love it and it's what I call the bedroom tone. For me, that position sounds great, excels at slap, but is just too scooped for my particular tone goals. Plenty of people use the HH basses in that setting though and it works just fine for them. There's no going wrong with either flavor of them, but the HH definitely has a wider choice of tones baked in. Since we're talking five-string basses, I found I could get a variety of tones with the H using the parallel/series+filter/series switch and adjusting the position of my fretting hand. If you like the StingRay 5 best in parallel mode, then the HH is definitely worth considering since it's entirely in parallel.