So I feel the need to offer up my opinion on the subject of which EHX BMS is better sounding, the old version or the new XO version. This past weekend I had a chance to play my Sad J-bass through and old BMS, and a new XO BMS. I used a Mesa BB750 and a PH1200 cab. Here are my results:
1) The low end tracking on the older version is about a million times better than the new XO version, the difference is actually disgusting. Playing a low to high sweep with most of the octave, guitar, and square wave sliders maxed the older version sounded full and rich with tons of low end while when trying to replicate the same sound on the newer version (some sliders were postioned a bit differently to try and find the sound) the XO farted out and sounded like shite.
2) The resonance slider on the new XO model has about 70% of its range crammed into about 10% of the sliders physical movement, the res slider is a lot better on the older version in terms of movement for sound use.
3) There were a few higher end filter sounds that I could get out of the XO version that I've never heard from an older version, I didn't really explore these as well as I could have because the tracking is SO bad that if you try to incorporate a little low end into a sound the XO just farts out.
4) The advantages to the XO are its size, jack locations, led indicator (instead of a power indicating led), power needs (although the new XO can't be daisy chained as far as I know, you still have to use the regulated power supply), and some new higher end filter tones. The XO's disadvantage is its tracking, total crap "IMO".
5) The advantages to the older version are it's sound, the tracking is vastly better than the XO, and the slider's movement in comparison the the sound change. The disadvantages are its size, jack locations, power supply (24v), power indicating led (always on), and total lack of anything close to true bypass.
So there it is "IMO".
I've chosen to buy a simple looper (
http://www.fuzzhugger.com/pedal-the-sidestep.html) and put my old version BMS in a loop. Its advantages far out weigh its disadvantages in my opinion. Anyone call me out on anything I might have done wrong. Peace, I'm out.