That is OCPD, a completely different disorder.
Are you always this desperate to try and be right about something?
We're discussing an off the hip comment that Jmatt made about his being a bit on the obsessive side when it comes to organization. At NO POINT did he insinuate ANYTHING about actually being OCD, but only that his friends sometimes JOKE around with him about it because of it.
I'm not sure if you're obsessively trying to diagnose him, but I doubt it's needed.
Maybe you're desperately attempting to correct his friends humor vicariously through me. Still pretty pointless, and channeled very poorly.
If you're attempting to correct me, I'm still a little confused as you MUST be aware that I was pretty clear in saying that those characteristics are IN LINE with OCD. Obviously more info would be needed, and a professional's diagnosis would help. BUT WE'RE NOT DIAGNOSING ANYONE HERE FRIEND!!!!!!
We're talking about a friendly joke among friends, said facetiously and most likely intended to be humorous.
I can't possibly think of a more irrelevant, pointless, ridiculous and useless debate we could be having here right now.
Nobody is attempting to officially diagnose anyone, and certainly they likely couldn't possibly care less if their description is/was scientifically accurate or not. I certainly do not.
But to entertain you a bit; The point as was OBVIOUSLY made, was that his need to clean was JOKINGLY comparable to a person with uncontrollable, & obsessive compulsions to clean, and organize IE; OCD.
Characteristics of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is an anxiety disorder, rather than a personality disorder, where you experience recurrent obsessions and compulsions.
Obsessions are:
Thoughts, images, or ideas that wont go away, are unwanted and cause extreme distress.
Accepted as coming from your own mind, but often feel impossible to control.
Not simply worries about your everyday problems.
Distressing enough to cause you to try to get rid of the obsessions with other thoughts or actions, like compulsions.
Compulsions are:
Behaviors that you feel you must carry out over and over.
Common compulsions include cleaning, counting, checking, requesting or demanding reassurance,
and ensuring order and symmetry.
As I said they are IN LINE with OCD.
Neither of us have enough information, or expertise to go any further with it.
I don't know though, maybe you're a therapist, LCSW, Psychiatrist, Etc and you're suffering from a little OCPD about your profession, and just can't let it go as a joking comment between friends.
If you are, I'm DEFINITELY not interested in the debate, my father is a therapist. I've had enough of the psych lessons to last me a life time. No thanks!!!!!
Lets just agree to disagree! Deal?
If it makes you feel better, I'll even go against my position, & say you're 100% correct, just so we can move past it.