Great thread!
I’ve been fascinated by the VI, since first seeing one in the Fender catalog, circa 1967. When I was first learning guitar, someone told my father that I should double on bass, because there’s always demand for bass players. When I saw the VI it occurred to me that this would make for an easy transition to bass. However, I don’t think I ever actually saw one, until many years later.
I finally got close with a Jaguar Baritone Custom, which was a 28.5” E-E instrument. I used it as a bass, but with that exceptionally short scale, the low E was too floppy. Later on, I bought a Custom Shop VI, which had its merits, but I never bonded with it. For reasons that evade logic, it just didn’t sound the way I wanted and didn’t sound half as good as the Jaguar Baritone Custom. So, for some years, I was six-less. One day, I decided to try eBay; lo and behold, there had been a run of Fender Japan VIs imported and I scored one in Candy Apple Red, with a matching headstock.
I’ve had several Fender Japan instruments and have always admired their quality. The VI was true to form, although the pickups were piercingly bright, something that was true of a Fender Japan Jaguar I had owned a few years earlier. I bought some Fender Pure Vintage Jaguar pickups and that made the character much more to my liking.
I can use mine as a bass and, depending upon how I select pickups, etc. the sound can go from a pretty convincing P-Bass thump to something that sounds like a Fender Jaguar’s uncle, and all points in between. I use LaBella flats and these seem to fit well with my tastes in sound and feel.
In my humble opinion, it’s a Swiss Army Knife of an instrument. It can fill the role of a bass, but it takes a bit of practice before you can find that sound. It is perfect for TicTac bass, if you use a pick. It can get an amazingly Funk sound, albeit slapping and popping are not really its greatest strength. It can do pretty much anything a B-B baritone can do, except hit the highest 4th of the range, but it makes for a great baritone effect in many tunes. Obviously the Duane Eddy inspired material is right up its alley, and it’s perfect for Surf. Jack Nitzche’s The Lonely Surfer features a VI, played by David Gates, and the sound is great.
Fairly early on in those thread, someone posted that it’s a good idea not to over analyze it, and think that is right on the money. Every instrument is a compromise, of some sort or another. The VI is good at many things, but it isn’t going to sound exactly like a P-Bass, a J-Bass, or anything else. If I got a call for a bass gig, I’d probably take it, play fingerstyle through a bass amp and it would do fine. IMO, it is worthy of being considered a bass (which really describes a tonal range, not an instrument).
Because of some tendonitis, I am restricted to 30” scale basses. While I miss some of my old 34” basses, I can’t say that I suffer in any way, because of the short scales of my basses. I have a CIJ Mustang, which sounds surprisingly good, dead stock. When my orthopedic surgeon suggested that I restrict myself to short scale basses, I had a short scale Warwick Corvette fretless, made to my specs. It has J-Style pickups, passive tone controls and has tremendous sustain. The VI fills a slightly different niche, but holds its own as a bass, and is more versatile than the Mustang. It’s really an excellent instrument.