TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Here's a qualifying question: Do people have to know they are bass players? People know who Sting is, but I'd bet far fewer know he plays the bass. Same for Paul McCartney. They just know they are singers and musicians. Remember, people are stupid.
I'd say you should add Flea; he as some level of cultural impact beyond RHCP
Maybe Jaco. Even my guitarists know who he was. There was a documentary about him with a lot of buzz.
Sadly, I doubt anyone outside bass players know who James Jamerson was.
Pink Floyd and Roger Waters are only well known to a specific audience.
I don't think they would know Gene's name either. The Average Joe doesn't know one guy from Kiss from another.I gotta go with Sting. Lots of youngsters (many around 20 years old...to around 30) know him and have no idea who Paul McCartney is. I know you guys will think I have bumped my head, but there are plenty of people around 20 or younger who have no idea who the Beatles were....not even from a historical standpoint.
Gene Simmons is right up there too. But, much like McCartney, most don't know he's the bass player.
Oh my..... You so widened my ever widening generation gap complex.... I was cool once.... I was cool once.... I was cool once...I would guess that Flea might be named the most by non bass players. Most people probably don't even know who Geddy Lee, Roger Waters, or James Jamerson are. A majority of people probably don't even realize that McCartney and Sting even play bass. RHCP has been around for a long time and are still relevant. He also has a pretty simple and unique name that people can remember along with some interesting stage antics.
Blasphemer!!!!Lots of youngsters (many around 20 years old...to around 30) know him and have no idea who Paul McCartney is. I know you guys will think I have bumped my head, but there are plenty of people around 20 or younger who have no idea who the Beatles were....not even from a historical standpoint.
I mostly get Sting, when people try to grope for a conversation point after hearing I'm a bassist. I don't think most recall Sir Paul played bass for the Beatles, they mostly think of him as a singer, same is true for Roger Waters, and likewise Gene Simmons is just the demon guy with the tongue. Only real fans or musicos know Geddy or Jamerson.
I would guess that Flea might be named the most by non bass players. Most people probably don't even know who Geddy Lee, Roger Waters, or James Jamerson are. A majority of people probably don't even realize that McCartney and Sting even play bass. RHCP has been around for a long time and are still relevant. He also has a pretty simple and unique name that people can remember along with some interesting stage antics.