• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fender American Original

I understand what you're saying here, I guess I didn't think of the 'reissue' tag.

My line of thinking was that a P bass is essentially a P bass, which is essentially a P bass. Be it a reissue, a signature model, an American Professional, American Standard, etc, it's essentially still the same body, same pickups (with some variation, but same configuration and basic design), same neck with minor shape, width and fret variations.

Does that make any sense? Not arguing or bashing Fender in the slightest.
Agreed. Unfortunately though, whenever Fender tried to re-create or re-design something "newer or fresh", it failed to the masses and was considered a flop. (re: Dimension)...its almost as if they're hands are somewhat tied.

I have a couple MIA P's, AND a Dimension IVHH......the Dimension (albeit a masses "flop"), is probably one of my fav basses to noodle around width - it's easy to play, great neck and has a ridiculous variety of tones. Having said that - the QC originally had some fret issues and a input jack short. Warranty covered that -

Infact, now that im thinking about it...my AVRI 63P, which i bought brand new, went back for some weird fret buzz and dead notes...(after having it a week) and they had to replace the entire neck! So, maybe its GOOD that Fender re-releases the same models year after year and tightens their QC. lol

I dont tend to be "brand loyal" in any sport/hobby...i buy what I like or suits ME.... Prob why i have Spectors, Fenders, Dingwalls, G&L, and a Wal.

My 1970 Fender P, of ALL my basses, does have one of the most stable necks in my fleet - luckily - cuz truss rod adjustments suuuuuuck having to take the neck off. So having some vintage goodies and some updated (truss rod) goodies, is my interest in that line up.

Regardless to what anyone buys (non-fender), they are still (and likely always WILL be), the benchmark everyone compares too. IMO
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wolfenstein666
I saw a "original" P bass at Guutar Center over the weekend. Have to say I was less than impressed. I didn't even play it. I picked it up and if you just told me to try it, I would have guessed that it was a low end Squier bass, not a $2k bass. IMO, the American Professional is a much better instrument. YMMV.
 
I think that the Vintage Reissues have been available now for so long that they are starting to enter "vintage" status themselves. It starts to seem a bit silly and meaningless..."Here's a vintage Vintage Reissue 62 Precision." It's a bit like when an artist starts to become a copy of or tribute to themselves...maybe then it's time to move on. They had to make a change to how reissues are perceived both now and down the line. So, rather than reproduce specific years and offerings maybe by thinking more in terms of "eras," 50's P Bass, 60's Jazz, etc., create a new series with it's own identity that has promise for continued appeal years from now. A 30 year old vintage "American Original" would still make sense to me...might even be cool. A 30 year old vintage "American Vintage Reissue" sounds a little bogus.

In any case, that American Original 60's P in Lake Placid Blue is really speaking to me.
 
Is it safe to assume that Fender did not do anything, bass wise, new besides the American originals? I thought that the MIM standards may get some sort of an upgrade. Or the Classic Series. Nothing was discontinued? Color added?
Judging by their appearance at NAMM yesterday, this certainly seems to be the case. I've only seen the American Originals, a couple out-of-my-price-range Custom Shop/Master Builds, and a 51 P bass with P/J pick-ups.
 
I decided to go for a '63 American Vintage P because they've gotten a price drop since the Original line was announced.

Can anyone who has experience with the last Vintage line speak to how they compare to the regular MIA Precision?

If you mean the american professional range the 63 is so much more vibey. The american pro series is very nice but a bit sterile. I bought an american pro and returned it for the 63 - i got double the value IMO. The 63 is just so shaging amazing.
 
I decided to go for a '63 American Vintage P because they've gotten a price drop since the Original line was announced.

Can anyone who has experience with the last Vintage line speak to how they compare to the regular MIA Precision?
Yes. The AVRI has a beefy neck and vintage frets and the regular mia has a slightly thinner neck and larger frets. The AVRI has a much better tone IMHO. Also the AVRI has a nitro finish and the MIA has a polyurethane finish.
 
Last edited:
Yes. The AVRI has a beefy neck and vintage frets and the regular mia has a slightly thinner neck and larger frets. The AVRI has a much better tone IMHO. Also the AVRI has a nitro finish and the MIA has a polyurethane finish.
IMO, the nitro finish makes a HUGE difference in the feel, look and even smell of the instrument. It feels like an old school hand crafted instrument. The AM Pro is really nice though. Could always do a mod shop american pro too.