+1
Playing them side by side is the way to go. In my case the local GC didn't have either bass in stock (the American Pro P-Bass or Elite P-Bass). So, I just ordered both basses. That way I could compare them with the stock Fender Nickel RW's and compare them with a new set of D'addario Chrome Flat's installed. Plus, I got to try them through my amp and cabinets. I played them through my rig and recorded them on various songs and listened over and over. I knew that I preferred the look and playability of the Elite P-Bass but my biggest concern was getting the true P-Bass sound and confirming that the Elite sounded great in the passive mode (as well as the active). I read so much conflicting opinions on TB that I didn't know what was true. Playing them side by side is THE way to go.
Also, since I ordered them through the local GC they were fine with me bringing back the one that I didn't want (with no return shipping charges).
Good luck with your choice!
The 2 that I compared ..... Both wonderful instruments!
View attachment 3200718