• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Final solution to soundmen

Status
Not open for further replies.
oh stop with the nazi stuff. yes, it was a horrible period in history, but it doesn't make someone a nazi to use the phrase "final solution." grow up.
 
Equal?!! NOT! For riding faders and punching effects?? Gimme a break... Well, okay, if you're making $100.00 or $200.00 a gig, maybe. After the sound check, how much does he actually do? I don't know about you, but I sing lead on about 35 songs a night, backups on the rest and play the entire thing.

Yeah it's not like your just moving your fingers and vocal chords or anything :p
 
i caqn't quite dis the soundman like that. on our gigs, the soundman is the first in and the last out and clearly has the longest day of any of us (and has a paycheck to match). but we don't own a pa and we either use house stuff or hire out. if you're in a band and everyone helps set up the pa/lights with the soundman, then i think what craig s said is legit. being a good soundman isn't easy, but after everything's set up it's not nearly as strenuous as singing and playing.
 
Godwin's Rule of Nazi Analogies

i read nazi somwhere wich meens this rule has come into play

Godwin's Law is often cited in online discussions as a deterrent against the use of arguments in the widespread reductio ad Hitlerum form. The rule does not make any statement about whether any particular reference or comparison to Adolf Hitler or the Nazis might be appropriate, but only asserts that the likelihood of such a reference or comparison arising increases as the discussion progresses. It is precisely because such a comparison or reference may sometimes be appropriate, Godwin has argued[4] that overuse of Nazi and Hitler comparisons should be avoided, because it robs the valid comparisons of their impact.
 
OP, go do some home recordings with your band. Without changing any effects or anything, really listen to the sound that's coming out. How audible are you? You all probably need a tone change.

In the studio, we discovered that both of my guitarists had way too much going on in the low-end and a lot of my bass and mids suffered because of it. I asked my guitarists to turn down the bass in their tones (that's what I'm for) and then I used a spectrum analyzer to quickly figure out which frequencies I needed to boost so that I could be audible and fill the spectrum without stepping on toes.

Our live sound has drastically improved, and if the FOH is bad, it's beyond our control.

Douchey thing for him to say outright, but it may not be without merit.
 
Not too long ago I had the misfortune of running into a series of sound men who were absolute I.K.E's ( I Know Everything) and the culmination of this was at a now defunct club were the posthole in question actually said

"I've met exactly 3 guys who knew what a bass should sound like, and you're not one of them"

screw that. i am so sick of soundmen who are on a big power trip because they run sound. but here's the funny thing...nobody ever pays to see a soundman run a board. without bands, a soundman has zero reason to exist, so instead of dictating terms, some soundmen ought to be a lot more humble and not say douchey things like "i'll ruin your sound if you annoy me" to the musicians. i'll ruin your paycheck if you say that to me on one of my gigs, you can bet your ass. and if i was the op, i would have been tempted to respond the exact same way. the club will eventually close...they all do, every single one of them. and the soundman is going to need a new job, and most musical circles are very small and tightly knit and everyone talks. i won't hesitate to throw a douchey soundman under the bus and cost him money.

HOWEVER...

i have worked with a lot of great soundmen who know a lot more than me and i have learned a lot from them. so try to learn from the good ones.

You & your band can play phenomenally, with absolutely orgasmic tones and still have an incompetent board operator/engineer make it sound horrible(i prefer not to use the term "sound man/guy" as they do NOT create any sound;) )....
Their only function is to assist you in sounding good, period. A function which most definitely does NOT include telling musicians that they don't know what their instrument and/or music should sound like !
Good board ops will not exhibit any "IKE" tendencies, GREAT ones are proactive and will ask you what you want/need and see that you get it.
 
I keep seeing these threads and here's what I do now


Not too long ago I had the misfortune of running into a series of sound men who were absolute I.K.E's ( I Know Everything) and the culmination of this was at a now defunct club were the posthole in question actually said

"I've met exactly 3 guys who knew what a bass should sound like, and you're not one of them"
Sounds just like TimmyP, except he's only heard 2 guys with exceptional bass tone.
 
The solution is simple - BRING YOUR OWN! Bring your own FOH engineer. For that matter, bring our own FOH system and bring your own monitor system. We do.

Your sound guy should also get an equal share for the gig. Ours does. They are working all night, just like you, and as instrumental to the sound of the band as any one individual.

My band often works with a greta soundguy, and thats only cuz I most often run our own sound, through our own PA. Even if there is a sound guy provided I most often prefer to bring my own stuff, unless I know the venues system and/or soundguy.
 
Equal?!! NOT! For riding faders and punching effects?? Gimme a break... Well, okay, if you're making $100.00 or $200.00 a gig, maybe. After the sound check, how much does he actually do? I don't know about you, but I sing lead on about 35 songs a night, backups on the rest and play the entire thing.

Yes, and each of those 35+ songs have different dynamics and could require slightly altered levels for each instrument depending on the song. When I run sound I dont just soundcheck levels and leave them there, Im constantly adjusting the board to maximize the sound for each song.
 
Yes, and each of those 35+ songs have different dynamics and could require slightly altered levels for each instrument depending on the song. When I run sound I dont just soundcheck levels and leave them there, Im constantly adjusting the board to maximize the sound for each song.
is that so hard? really?
 
is that so hard? really?

When you have to haul all the gear and set up an hour before the show, stay through an entire night (that cold be anywhere from 6-8 hours) break down all that gear before you leave, yes it can be. Not to mention having to sit through and try and make some really bad bands sound good, it can be very strenuous. And then you have musicians who sometimes don't know what theyre talking about try and order you around, it can be annnoying as well. A lot harder than just playing a few sets for sure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.