• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fretless in rock?

i thought JPJones used a fretless P live?(seems like i read that somewhere),,should qualify as`rock'

For one song, In My Time of Dying. It's a P Bass, w/ maple FB, I think it's an early "ish" 70's.

Here is the bass in question from 1975:
YouTube - Led Zeppelin - In My Time of Dying (Live Earls Court 1975)

You can see it quite a bit during Page's solo.

And here is the same bass in 2007:
YouTube - LED ZEPPELIN "IN MY TIME OF DYING" LIVE LONDON REUNION CONCERT 2007 -COMPLETE PERFORMANCE

You can see it really well @ about 00:20
 
Don't remember who it was, but Robert Plant's bass player, from maybe his second (third?) solo album on used fretless quite a bit.

Then there is Pino with Paul Young (OK - might not be "rock.....").

Oh, and I think it's Pino playing fretless again on much of Don Henly's early solo work.
 
Don't remember who it was, but Robert Plant's bass player, from maybe his second (third?) solo album on used fretless quite a bit.

Then there is Pino with Paul Young (OK - might not be "rock.....").

Oh, and I think it's Pino playing fretless again on much of Don Henly's early solo work.

Charlie Jones played with Plant.

Pino played on "Sunset Grille" on Henley's "Building the Perfect Beast"

Larry Klein played the killer fretless line on "Boys of Summer".
 
Dee Murray on Elton John's early albums, best heard on the 11/17/70 live album.

And.......Me! I play fretless exclusively. And as someone said previously, you usually can't tell by listening (that's intentional).

Hmm... I'd like proof (of the first one, not the second!). I've never seen any pictures of Dee with a fretless, and there's nothing in the sound or performance of "11/17/70" to indicate he's playing fretless there at all. Except for two songs, Dee didn't play on Elton John albums except "11/17/70" until "Honky Château" in 1972. He's not on the "Elton John" at all. He plays on "Amoreena" from "Tumbleweed Connection" (though he and Nigel sing on a few others) and on "All The Nasties" from "Madman Across The Waters". BTW, "All The Nasties" is the first recorded example of what became The Elton John Band of Dee, Nigel, and Davey Johnstone.

John