• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fretless P

Mighty Mite ebonol fretless neck on a poplar body and a Joe Barden pickup --- plays great and the neck wasn't expensive at all. It has the P bass neck profile that is very thin front to back and is not a baseball bat. The nut that came on it is rather soft material - one of these days I'll cut a bone nut for it. But I'm very pleased with how it feels and sounds.
View attachment 3266610


That's a gorgeous bass!
 
  • Like
Reactions: AndyPanda
That's a gorgeous bass!
Thanks! What's funny is I bought the body on the classified here and asked around about staining it and was told to paint it because Poplar has an ugly grain that doesn't lend itself to stain. And in my typical fashion I ignored the advice and stained it anyway. This is what the body looked like when I bought it on the classifieds:
Body (1).jpeg
 
My first bass guitar was a 1975 Fretless Precision, still have it and play it about once a month at church. Mighty Mite necks are good quality but there are others that are cheaper if you just want to experiment. I have defretted a bass but the nut needs the slots filed and the fall away at the high end of the board (above the 15th fret line) must be sanded so a radius block should be used ime. Here is my choice for an inexpensive playable fretless neck;

SX Bass Neck Ursa 1 MN Fretless - RondoMusic.com

SX Bass Neck Ursa 1 RN Fretless - RondoMusic.com

These are $50 plus shipping from New Hampshire and I have been very satisfied with the quality of Rondo gear. My main gigging bass is presently a $139 Douglas Bass from them and it is well beyond the quality of any Squier Affinity series bass I have played, and compares favorably with an MIM Fender imo. If you just want a fretless to play with to try out on the cheap this may be it. Remember that any neck change may require either neck or body work to fit properly. If you are not handy with wood you may need help. In that case (or if you want to spend enough to get a giggable complete bass cheap) go get a new Squier VM P or CV P bass. You can't go wrong with those, every one I have played was a winner. Just my .03 ymmv

PS Rondo often has decent quality inexpensive fretless basses, I would have recommended an SX bass from Rondo but at present they are out of stock.
 
Last edited:
Has anyone bought a fretless neck and put it on a P bass? I'm curious about this configuration. I have a MIM P and I would also like to try a fretless without a major cash outlay. Also I don't want a cheapie sitting around if I don't like it. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks!!!!!

I bought a loaded MIM Fender P body and a fretless Warmoth neck. I love it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TN WOODMAN
Has anyone bought a fretless neck and put it on a P bass? I'm curious about this configuration. I have a MIM P and I would also like to try a fretless without a major cash outlay. Also I don't want a cheapie sitting around if I don't like it. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks!!!!!

I owned one like this and it was pretty cool! No real input that would be different from any other fretless advice. Go for it and put the time in to practice, it's worth it.

Unlined looks cooler ;)
 
I have two aftermarket fretless necks. One is a Mighty Mite ebonal and the other is a plain maple board (no lines, dots or side dots). The maple is on an orange Jazz Bass with gold hardware and guard. The ebonal was (until a few weeks ago) on a P bass with a '60's or '70's Gibson mudbucker in the neck position and a Duncan quarter pounder Pup. It was supposed to sound as close to a DB as possible without losing the ability to sound like a P bass. It did.
 
In addition to the Warmoth and Mighty Mite recommendations, take a look at "thestratosphere" on ebay, reverb or their website. They sometime have used fretless necks available. Also, there's a seller on eBay, "postlang" who sells various unfinished and finished AllParts necks for Fender basses, including fretless.

I paired a '13 Jazz neck with a '16 Am Std Precision body a few years ago. That was an awesome bass...another I wish I still had.

I have also had experience doing business with "thestratosphere" on eBay. Most of my purchases turned out to be decent quality but the shipping times were often around 45 days. At that price there is an eBay seller in Kentucky selling better quality necks that are near or better in quality to Mighty Mite, but he has limited availability (like Rondo) so it may not be available now.
 
A while back someone on here had a 5-string Cavin/Kiesel P that was a single pickup. It was gorgeous and sounded really cool and unique. He did some Mingus clips on it that sounded killer. I’m sure the thread is still floating around here somewhere.
 
23FFB834-55C3-43A5-A12A-04FAADFFF41A.jpeg
Here’s my fret less P with J pickups, it has a USA Jazz neck. It’s lovely!

There are plenty of reasonably priced fretless jazz necks that come on the market. The Japanese ones are really nice, but don’t usually have lines, if you want a lined one, try to find a Mexican, USA, or aftermarket one. Best of luck, happy new year!!!
 
The Squier VM Fretless line all have issues. Expect to do work if you want a great playing Squier VM Fretless. The VM P I had, for example, required the board levelled, the nut cut, and a HUGE shim just to get the thing in playing condition. While they don't all require the shim, they do all require the board levelling and nut cut in my experience. The stock pickups are alright but they are super hot and super bland.

Maybe all the ones you have had had issues. The ones I've owned or played have mostly been fine.

Statistically, a Squier VM fretless - J or P - will need attention. I've picked up and played well over a dozen now and every one had issues with raised lines, 'ripple' in the playing surface and poorly cut nut slots, that is to say not deep enough. Unless extra time/$$ are factored in for getting these things fixed, the VM fretless experience will be far from pleasurable, not representative and potentially highly frustrating. For the price of a new VM, the same $$ will buy a high quality neck and a decent set of tuners, at least it will on my side of the pond... YMMV.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DiabolusInMusic
I've defretted a couple basses but never bought a replacement neck. This Mighty Mite looks tempting - would want to be clear on any position markings before buying though.
Invalid Link Removed

I use one of these on my #1 jazz. It is one of the better fretless necks I have had. It is unlined but that could be part of the fun.