I always see people who say they want this guy's tone or that guys tone. I have even done it myself before. Although that might be a great start to get you in the ballpark.
Why not make your OWN tone. That way maybe one day people on Talkbass will be like..."man...I want that guys tone".
I both agree and disagree at the same time. My favorite bassist's tone has changed over the years, but I like some of his earliest tones the best. Once I make up synth parts, drums...maybe singing one day.....finding my "own tone" has probably already happened. But I don't care if it doesn't. I want to continue my favorite bassists "old tone" because I hear it in the music that is in my head and it goes well with the contrasting synth parts I come up with really well. (soft/abrasive)
And, like that bassist, my tone changes a little from song to song. I like metallic grind, and for my top end to sound like a tin can. Can I make it blatant in every song? No, but I can get some of my character to slip through in a lot of stuff I do. (I have a friend who sometimes disagrees with that tone until he hears in context)
Did a bassist I follow even care about that sound? I don't know, but it's what makes me want to play bass. If bass sounds dull, I quickly lose interest in the instrument as a whole. I guess I'm a mix of a guitarist and bassist in that regard. If it were one band, I'd say I like to incorporate parts of Adam Clayton and The Edge 50/50 into my sound.
I guess I'm trying to say it doesn't matter how you get there, as long as music comes out. Nobody has ever gone and said to me "You sound just like Faith No More" or "M83" because I don't think I ever will. I have gotten "That sounds like Billy Gould joined the Cocteau Twins" before. I consider that a big compliment. Both are a big influence on me, and the arcane pathways I use to sound like both makes something completely different. I think that's the way it is anyway - Jaco even copped other players, except he kept what he liked and tossed what he didn't about them.
I think Talkbass as a whole doesn't represent real-world many times, and people grossly over-think things. And I also agree you CAN waste too much time not being creative to focus so much on tone. I've definitely been there
