In french we say " sois belle et tais toi ".
"Be Beautiful But Shut Up"
that's how Google translated it. Nice.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
In french we say " sois belle et tais toi ".
this should be the motto of every new actor/actress in hollywood"Be Beautiful But Shut Up"
that's how Google translated it. Nice.
It struck me then that on the level of big tours with big names, PERSONALITY is SO much more important of a hiring decision than is playing ultimately.
Hadrien Feraud has the chops to be a solo star, and it seems that is where his head is at this time. If that is what he chooses to do, more power to him. Then, he can tell the guitarist to turn it down!
As for being good but unobtrusive, that is the key for the rest of us.![]()
Had a similar experience last night. I was contracted to provide music for a corporate event for folks "in their 30s and 40s who have been in meetings all day and will want to have some fun" from 6-9. And that they wanted "quiet but not boring". So the expectation was that we were a bit more than just wallpaper.
I have a great trio that I work with and we added a horn for some variety. We started off, drummer on brushes and electric keyboard. And right away the request was to bring it down which we did. There were a numbers of folks with heads bobbing coming into the room so we thought we were OK. But still we had to turn down. We told the horn player to take a break and played as a trio. Still getting requests to turn down and by this point I could barely hear myself over the talking in the room let alone the high hat and keys when playing some standards.
I've never played so quiet in my life. I've played for other functions at this location and never had a problem. Even had a vocalist in the same room. Thanks goodness we use the electric keyboard with volume control as opposed to the usually out of tune baby grand. We'd have been toast at that point.
In end we were told the gig was done at 7:15. We still got paid our $250 each. We did our level best to respond to the customer but in the end it wasn't good enough.
What would I do differently? Probably not hire a horn player. But other than that all the lead up into the booking indicated we were on the right track. I suppose you could say we got fired like HF.
EDIT - this was also the first function that the organizer had done perhaps they did not assess the needs of their client as well as could have been. As mentioned we had a few folks smiling and moving to the music but ultimately it was the call of one of the VP to end the gig. I've since talked to the organizer who reassured me that it was not our fault and he would call when he get a client with better ears.
One of my favorite quotes from a respected bassist about this very topic came from David Hofstra (in, I believe, the very first issue of Bass Player magazine). When asked "What is it you do as a musician that keeps people calling you back for gigs?" Hofstra replied
"I show up on time."
Real professional musicians that actually have chops aren't going to get fired for being to loud after being told multiple times that they are too loud. Awareness is very much a key component of ones chops.
I think getting fired from a gig as big as JM's band for being unable to turn down is remarkable. There has to be more to it.
I wonder if HF's technique had something to do with it. It seems as if he has very low action (since he uses a ramp) and probably needs to keep his bass turned up very loud to produce any volume. If he had to dig in, the notes might be choked and fretted out.
Just pondering.
I think getting fired from a gig as big as JM's band for being unable to turn down is remarkable. There has to be more to it.
I wonder if HF's technique had something to do with it. It seems as if he has very low action (since he uses a ramp) and probably needs to keep his bass turned up very loud to produce any volume. If he had to dig in, the notes might be choked and fretted out.
Just pondering.
Obviously, it's time for Hadrien to put his own band together and do his own music. There are not a whole lot of "farm team" gigs available for someone at that level. As Gary intimated, Jeff Berlin underwent the same situation as a young player with Alan Holdsworth (I remember talking with Alan about his switch to Jimmy Johnson in 1985 at the NAMM Show in New Orleans) and Jaco with Weather Report (although it's really clear from biographies and such that there were extra-musical issues there).
In my personal life, I found that the only way to get my entire musical vision out was to put together my own band, start writing, and decide what to do musically myself. Any time I am working FOR someone else's musical vision I am in service to that at the time. I think that's what makes a successful bassist.
Also, busy drummer+busy bassist=conflict. Someone has to mind the store, IME....
he's a kid who's probably used to being told how great he is and probably didn't face much adversity in the past. he'll pick up on it. or he'll be a solo act from here on out![]()
One thing I noticed... I didn't see Mark Mondesir's name mentioned.
He was the drummer in the mclaughlin band with feraud on bass when gary husband played mainly keyboards...
I'd be interested to hear what he has to say about Hf now.
I think the early word was positive.
That's a while ago however...
Mondesir is on the latest album with M'Bappe, I love his playing!