No pain no gain
It will toughen you up some, grow a beard, more chest hair, you will eat nails for breakfast and poop out barbed wire fence by noon. Your hands will have the strength of ten men. You will bench press a buick.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
It will toughen you up some, grow a beard, more chest hair, you will eat nails for breakfast and poop out barbed wire fence by noon. Your hands will have the strength of ten men. You will bench press a buick.
Everyone has different hands. For some, short scales are more comfortable. Personally I prefer medium-long scale, but having more options is better, right?
My only 2 basses are a Fender Jazz and a cheapo (not Hofner) violin bass. The violin is the go to practice bass and my favourite as it's miles easier to play. Add a pre-amp, a compressor/limiter, a reverb pedal, much better strings and eventually it sounds alright.
Perhaps some of us don't feel the need to overcompensate?
I get it from a practical point of view....but just no. Im sure there are lovers of the headless thing, they make me want to vomit just looking at them.
The balance on headless instruments is perfect and they tend to be a lot lighter. I tried out a friend's Status Streamliner for a few rehearsals and while it literally looks like a canoe paddle and not in a good way, it played very well, sounded really good, and was by far and away the most comfortable bass I've ever used. Yeah, they ain't too pretty but ergonomically they just make sense. Sometimes the best and most practical solutions aren't the most attractive ones. I love my Warwick Thumb but it weighs a ton, balance is a bit weird and it gives me shoulder pains on long gigs.
If (gods forbid) I ever have any sort of injury or disability in the future and need to switch to instruments that are easier to play, a short-scale headless bass like a Fodera Imperial Mini would probably be ideal (plus would require me to sell off all my other basses which would be pointless to own anyway). I know someone on this forum plays a Marleaux Soprano purely due to bad case of early-onset arthritis.
Plus, short scale basses are GREAT for kids to get into.
I like Status or Kiesel Vaders Headless basses, but yes not the paddle looking ones. I like short scales as well, I mean to me that's one of the best things about Basses - choice (headless, short scale, 5 string, fingerstyle, pick, active, passive, etc..) Whatever feels right to you is what you need.
I play my 30" about 50% of the time. It is great for sitting down while at the PC, but also very lightweight. I usually carry it to gigs as my backup bass, too. I think as long as you have the right strings, playing a short scale is no problem. I tune all my basses to DGCF, including the short scale (but I am thinking about doing a BEAD-tuning on one of my 34" basses). 5 strings just feel wrong to me.
When it comes to upper frets, that is certainly a challenge, but to me it's easier to overcome than some of the finger-stretching excercises of covering 4 or 5 frets with your hand at the far end of a long scale.
As a member of this club, I think it's not a question of one size fits all. It's a question of what works for you: Squier Jaguar Short Scale Club Part 3
When it comes to upper frets, that is certainly a challenge, but to me it's easier to overcome than some of the finger-stretching excercises of covering 4 or 5 frets with your hand at the far end of a long scale.
As a member of this club, I think it's not a question of one size fits all. It's a question of what works for you: Squier Jaguar Short Scale Club Part 3
It's ugly without the cover, because the stick pickguard is cut for a strat size pickup, and putting a p-bass pickup in there means that part of the original pickup rout remains. a little hard to explain, but the footprint of the p-bass pickup does not completely cover the hole for the strat pickup. I have a pickguard blank coming and I'll make a new guard. Headstock has my own logo on it
madbass6
Inactive
- Jan 13, 2009
- 2,428
- 1,295
- Disclosures
- I do not give consent to use any of my photos ! please respect that. thank you.
Agree 100%!!
Personally, I like my basses to feel like weapons!
Back in the day a memeber here bought one of those micro's and donated it to a girl who had spinabifida, should have seen the look on her face. She was sooo happy. I wish I could remember the member who donated it and the member who made the original post. It was super cool, over 10 years ago now.
I guess I use the example to show a very important reason why they may exist. Those who physically are unable to cope with the standard sized instrument.
I guess I use the example to show a very important reason why they may exist. Those who physically are unable to cope with the standard sized instrument.
Rickenbackers are slightly shorter scale than a jazz, at 33.25" scale, too.
I'm pretty sure Boaty is a woman, so may or may not necessarily want to grow a beard and chest hair. I'm a dude, and I would prefer not to poop barbed wire.No pain no gain
I did a fair bit of time in Singapore (good place for cheap effect and amp gear), some of the local hot dishes felt like pooping barbed wire the next day.
Over a lifetime I've learned there is a common condition among many people I dubbed " that ain't me so it can't be". We really don't have to reconcile other's preferences with our own.
I generally strongly prefer a long scale bass, but for sit down playing, short scale works better for me. Recently I got my hands on a friend's Danelectro Longhorn and I couldn't believe how much I dug it. Now I had to go and order one. It will fit in a typical electric guitar case and will be excellent for traveling.
Don't play one. Problem solved.
