I've tried that too and it hurts like hell and I nearly ripped of my fingernail----->not a good idea
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
How do you pop
- Thread starter i like tictacs
- Start date
AQUANOVA
I'd agree with you, but then we'd both be wrong
One thing I've noticed that many beginners do when trying to pop is getting the motion by moving their arm at the elbow joint ( you're not playing Ping Pong ).
The correct and most efficient way is to rotate your forearm and keep your elbow stationary. This will give you more control and teach you that playing good slap pop is about finesse. And when done right should not hurt your arm or fingers.
The correct and most efficient way is to rotate your forearm and keep your elbow stationary. This will give you more control and teach you that playing good slap pop is about finesse. And when done right should not hurt your arm or fingers.
jeanbaudin said:
I tried that (right after the first time I heard you did it), but it wasn't my thing.
- Aug 27, 2003
- 1,413
- 183
- Disclosures
- Endorsing Artist: See Profile
yeah, I definitely don't recommend the fingernail popping technique... it hurts and if your nail breaks you can't slap.
The reason I do it that way is my first custom bass had frets that covered that little space you are supposed to pop at so I had to come up with a different way to slap/pop. Apparently, Michael Manring had to go through the same thing with his Hyperbass (he came up with the finger stroke/rake thing).
For me, I've got it down so it doesn't hurt at all and I can pop with all of my fingernails so if one breaks I just go the next one. But every student I've shown it too gives up after a week.
The reason I do it that way is my first custom bass had frets that covered that little space you are supposed to pop at so I had to come up with a different way to slap/pop. Apparently, Michael Manring had to go through the same thing with his Hyperbass (he came up with the finger stroke/rake thing).
For me, I've got it down so it doesn't hurt at all and I can pop with all of my fingernails so if one breaks I just go the next one. But every student I've shown it too gives up after a week.
Thats what I do, but i sometimes hook... When i get carried away, i use too much finger and regret it when i have no skin on my fingertip left. However, that does make an interesting conversation piece.i like tictacs said:
Jean said:
"For me, I've got it down so it doesn't hurt at all and I can pop with all of my fingernails so if one breaks I just go the next one. But every student I've shown it too gives up after a week."
What strikes me about that is if your nails are long enough to pop with, then aren't they too long to play a regular, smooth finger-style without the nails clicking across the string?
That's something I have to be careful about - as soon as one gets just a smidge too long... I mean now that I think about it, just last band practice I stopped the guys between songs, and went to the bass case for the clippers, saying "Sorry guys, just a second here - this is driving me nuts".
Joe
"For me, I've got it down so it doesn't hurt at all and I can pop with all of my fingernails so if one breaks I just go the next one. But every student I've shown it too gives up after a week."
What strikes me about that is if your nails are long enough to pop with, then aren't they too long to play a regular, smooth finger-style without the nails clicking across the string?
That's something I have to be careful about - as soon as one gets just a smidge too long... I mean now that I think about it, just last band practice I stopped the guys between songs, and went to the bass case for the clippers, saying "Sorry guys, just a second here - this is driving me nuts".
Joe
Well, I begin by taking down my pants, then I sit on the bowl, and then...
Oops, I misread the thread title.
Oops, I misread the thread title.
Actually, you don't need long nails at all to catch a string. It's a common misconception that you do, many people think classical guitarists, for example, need long nails. In reality, long nails are more a hindrance than a help. They break, they get caught when they shouldn't, ick.
