• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How far would you lower standards?

YES...Friday is a disaster. Yes...Rebecca Black was a kid with rich parents who indulged her. That said...she took being a national punchline in stride, went back to the drawing board, learned how to sing for real, and released more music that is at least as "good" as the rest of the pop on the radio (or any of the singing shows).

Not MY thing...mind you...but you have to give the girl props for sticking to her dreams and making it happen.

Sure, but my point wasn't to trash her -- hers was the first video that came to mind where I knew it had tons of views and tons of dislikes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pirate Captain
:laugh:
I really did LOL.
Well, entertaining for a few seconds and I guess it is a good "teen-appreciated" spoof on death metal voicing. OK, hurrah for her 5 minutes of fame.

And she is cute enough so that I'd rather see her with Robert Palmer and see how she might fit into this:



or




Damn! I just derailed my own thread. :rollno: :facepalm:
 
Last edited:
Funny though, how cover tune discussions always seem to go:

Who knows how to play song x, guitarist doesn't so it's out. How about song y, nope drummer and singer don't know it. How about song z, bassist doesn't know it, so what he can just play the roots, okay we have a winner, learn it by showtime tonite.

Yes, the thing is with jams, that people shows up that doesn't know Dm but still THINK they can jam. The part of your thing above, is that I can YELL OUT chords to the gtrd as we go along if he doesn't know the chords and tag along and get it basically on the second verse. Then it's most crucial that ANYONE in the band can react to yell out keys and chords throughout the song, and by the second verse/refrain they'll get it. I e that you can cue people.

You can't cue clueless people.

- - - - -

These days, most rehearsal spaces has internet connections too, and wireless. So we have this computer hooked up to a projector on a shelf high up, that lights up the other wall end of the rehearsal space and it's 3-4 meters wide. We hook up to the internet, shows a song lyrics (people ALWAYS forgets lyrics at jams) and with the chords underneath it and jam along. If there's someone who hasn't heard it, we just swap tabs inside any browser and connect to iTunes, Spotify, or YouTube to play the first round for the novice, and they'll go "uh uh"... and get the general vibe tempo and flow from the song. The we threw ourselves headlong into it. Of course, it's mostly cover type stuff short songs, and no long form progressive stuff, with changes and polyrhythms. This is better than the singer headdiving into their small cellphones while singing a text. And for jazz, all fakebooks are online anyway..so we just bring them up on that whyteboard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MEKer
It's funny. Most people that have asked me to be in their band, it hasn't been mutual. I e when some stranger shows up after a gig, and ask me to be in their band without having heard any of them. When I checked them out ... it's almost always...meh... one seems to be some kind of magnet to those with lesser skills. No one with better skills than me has ever never came up to me and asked me to play for them either, and vice versa. I know my limits and limitations and won't force my lesser skills upon someone elses band provided that I've detected that they're superior to me. It has to do with rehearsing. If it takes longer time for me to hone it, than the others they'll know that I am going to drag them down and it's a large speed bump in their road. My forte lies in the stamina, session on ends without getting fatigued, and the musical memory to learn fast. If it's "regular covers", by the second verse or the repeats in any song, I can mostly stop looking at the charts, lyrics with chords, and have memorized it. With jazz tunes, it's mostly form and codas and 1st 2nd repeats that has different chords, and so on... YMMV.

But I still find it peculiar why people who have the DK-syndrome always asks the ones with MUCH better skills to partake in their projects. I think it all boils down to that whenever they hear someone else playing - at their own level - they don't think it's worth listening to, or playing with. Cognitive bias, and it's basically called the Ikea Effect.
 
At a jam, well, everyone brings what they got. Some obviously bring more to the table than others. I'll sit in ... for a while ... maybe (and likely not return). Worse, IMO, is when someone in the jam group says "hey, we should form a band". That's my cue ... exit stage left. I much prefer to jam with people I know and who have some smattering of musical knowledge. We get together at a friend's large house and have bimonthly "kitchen pickin'" sessions. Usually about 10 seasoned, knowledgable semi-pros (all have actively gigging projects). A little music, some pizza, a few brews and "whatever", swapping gig stories, introducing new songs still wet behind the ears. No competition, no pressure, no poaching (grin!).
 
Wow, I had never heard of "the Ikea effect" before, cool.

IKEA effect - Wikipedia

Substitute the word furniture with music/playing, and you're off to go.

"They fall in love with their IKEA creations. Even when there are parts missing and the items are incorrectly built, customers in the IKEA study still loved the fruits of their labors. And automatically thinks that other thinks it too."


While this is nothing new, everyone is proud of their work of course, but they not only think that it's better than anyone elses creations, the main difference is that they think others will think the same about their own work, although it looks, and finishes the same or way worse.
 
IKEA effect - Wikipedia

Substitute the word furniture with music/playing, and you're off to go.

"They fall in love with their IKEA creations. Even when there are parts missing and the items are incorrectly built, customers in the IKEA study still loved the fruits of their labors. And automatically thinks that other thinks it too."


While this is nothing new, everyone is proud of their work of course, but they not only think that it's better than anyone elses creations, the main difference is that they think others will think the same about their own work, although it looks, and finishes the same or way worse.
Never heard that expression before - and I'm Swede, living with my Billy bookshelves an all...
Thanks!