Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
How important do you consider a good drummer?
- Thread starter cantstoplt021
- Start date
Very important, all the time.
Unless I'm playing bluegrass, I'm a snob and insist on no drums in my bluegrass
If the drummer sucks, I'll only do the gig for a fair chunk of money. But even if the money was good it still wouldn't be enough to keep me around for long.
Unless I'm playing bluegrass, I'm a snob and insist on no drums in my bluegrass
If the drummer sucks, I'll only do the gig for a fair chunk of money. But even if the money was good it still wouldn't be enough to keep me around for long.
A good drummer + a good bass player can make pretty much any band good. You cannot say that about any of the other pieces. My brothers (drummers) and I carried many green/hack guitar players and singers back in the day. Long as the rhythm section is good, people dance, and they think the singer/guitar player are better.
So in answer to your question - mandatory. I'd have zero interest in playing in a band with a bad drummer, and I can't think of a single successful one I've seen on any level.
So in answer to your question - mandatory. I'd have zero interest in playing in a band with a bad drummer, and I can't think of a single successful one I've seen on any level.
"A band is only as good as it's drummer"
-Gasman
Drummer is the most important musician in the band. Because he/she is the only one that can ruin every song by being a bit off. Everyone else can cover a flubbed note. Not the drums.
BTW the quote above is one I've been saying for over 15 years. And it is universally true.
-Gasman
Drummer is the most important musician in the band. Because he/she is the only one that can ruin every song by being a bit off. Everyone else can cover a flubbed note. Not the drums.
BTW the quote above is one I've been saying for over 15 years. And it is universally true.
The drummer is the most important, followed by the singer(s).
Actually, everyone in the band is important, but a bad drummer and/or singer will just sink a band.
Actually, everyone in the band is important, but a bad drummer and/or singer will just sink a band.
SirMjac28
Patiently Waiting For The Next British Invasion
It's vital. A good drummer vastly improves the sound and performance of any ensemble. In many cases, the drummer may be the most important person in a rock quartet or trio.
I played with a very talented drummer once. He couldn't keep time worth a damn. He was gifted a practice pad and when it told him his timing horrible he threw it away in disgust. Refused to believe it. songs always end much faster than they begin and he claimed it was just us "getting into it." He was a self proclaimed "hardcore drummer" HAH
Talented but doing nothing with it. Shame.
Talented but doing nothing with it. Shame.
I'd agree with everyone on the front page (didn't read all 9- whoops!), a drummer is essential for the bassist to play with. They make up the rhythm section of the song.
Singers are not important at all in bands that don't have them. They can also ruin a great band.
Late to the game here, but I'd say that in addition to many other factors probably mentioned in this thread, one thing I've noticed over the last couple of years in writing and jamming is that a good summer playing an interesting beat is often the difference between guitar riffs sounding generic or sounding interesting and creative.
ex·treme·ly
ikˈstrēmlē/
adverb
ikˈstrēmlē/
adverb
- to a very great degree; very.
synonyms: very, exceedingly, exceptionally, especially, extraordinarily, in the extreme,tremendously, immensely, vastly, hugely, intensely, acutely, singularly,uncommonly, unusually, decidedly, particularly, supremely, highly,remarkably, really, truly, mightily
Think it was all said on first page
What sane Bass player with any skills could tolerate a weak drummer
What sane Bass player with any skills could tolerate a weak drummer
I'll bite:
My first band was formed at the end of my freshman year of high school. Everyone in said band was capable of performing our songs true to the records and with energy...except the drummer. His timekeeping was average, and he frequently missed/added sections to songs.
Overall band talent rating IMO: 8/10. We were good, but not great at what we wanted to do.
My second band was formed just before my senior year of high school. I played keys and had to label the note names...because I had never played keys before. Our bassist had played for about six months...two years prior when he broke his leg. Our rhythm guitarist was kinda like me - he had only ever played violin.
This was all balanced a bit by a great lead guitarist and singer...but it was our drummer that made the band good. I actually hugged him after our first practice because he made playing in a group so easy. Atomic-clock-level consistency in tempo, and he could play every song solo with the correct structure.
Overall band talent rating IMO: well, three threes and three tens average out to a 6.5.
The second band got way more gigs, actually made some money, and was much more enjoyable to play with. It didn't even matter that three of us were beginners.
My first band was formed at the end of my freshman year of high school. Everyone in said band was capable of performing our songs true to the records and with energy...except the drummer. His timekeeping was average, and he frequently missed/added sections to songs.
Overall band talent rating IMO: 8/10. We were good, but not great at what we wanted to do.
My second band was formed just before my senior year of high school. I played keys and had to label the note names...because I had never played keys before. Our bassist had played for about six months...two years prior when he broke his leg. Our rhythm guitarist was kinda like me - he had only ever played violin.
This was all balanced a bit by a great lead guitarist and singer...but it was our drummer that made the band good. I actually hugged him after our first practice because he made playing in a group so easy. Atomic-clock-level consistency in tempo, and he could play every song solo with the correct structure.
Overall band talent rating IMO: well, three threes and three tens average out to a 6.5.
The second band got way more gigs, actually made some money, and was much more enjoyable to play with. It didn't even matter that three of us were beginners.
