• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How to become good... really good...

How many years does it take? Does everything depend on how much I play or am I already doomed to be average because of small hands?
To answer your first question...It will take you the rest of your life. The day you quit practicing is the day you end your musical aspirations. Music and musicianship is a journey. Enjoy the ride.
To address your second question, I once saw a guy at a blues festival that was missing most of his fingers on his left hand to the 2nd knuckle. The guy absolutely ripped on the bass! He was amazing! Not only because of what he overcame, but because you could not tell he had any sort of disability. Had I not seen it with my own eyes, I would have never thought anything was different about him. I am the biggest limiting factor in my ability as a musician. I suspect it is the same for you.
 
I found after mundane hours of practicing scales and theory the thing that single handedly improved my bass playing was my physical condition. I went on a diet and exercised as part of my rehearsal routine.
I know this sounds weird, what does exercise have to do with musical ability. Where being in good health doesn't make you a better musician it does make you able to perform better under high energy/stress situations.
For example my band we have our normal jam session style practice, then we have a full stage show rehearsal, then we run 3 miles as a band. Come back have a jam session. Now exhausted mentally and physically, perform.
What this has done for me as a musician is be able to take any stage at anytime and be comfortable. I'm not up on a stage with lights beating down on me, mentally and physically exhausted, I am in my element. This has helped me prepare for any moment I have went to perform and was already exhausted from lack of sleep, to much stress, or starving cause I forgot to eat.
How did this make me a better bass player? Well it taught me to still be able to use all the hours of scales and theory and use them when I was at my mental and physical done.

You can practice 2,8,10, heck 18 hours a day and none of that means a thing when you can't think because the hot stage lights are beating down on you in a gig in Texas on a summers eve or you play a festival in the day in direct sunlight. So unless you dream of being a studio musician or a music store idol, good health is essential.
In short I feel it is as important to physically be in as good as shape as your ability to play. Also I lost over 70lbs and feel and look better then ever! My bass playing has improved, my ability to have my instrument in a comfortable position (gut pushes bass out and causes you to have your wrist in a unnatural position) is improved, back problems went away and I became more comfortable with my bass.
Does this mean you have to be in good physical health to be a phenomenal bassist? Absolutely not, eat pizza, donuts, dingdongs, and whatever you want, go out on stage and be on the verge of a stroke or look like you fell into the pool. You will still be a great bass player. I'm merely saying good health is important even in music.

So take it as you will. Please anyone overweight that takes offense to this. That is a personal issue just as this is a personal opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Felken
Jaco used to practice every waking hour and would only take breaks to eat, clean up and sleep. Most really great bassists put a whole lot of time in above and beyond 2 hours a day. And they're always pushing themselves to get better at the things they're weak on.
 
I remember this long interview. His response to other bass players: do you know how to read?
Well, along the lines of physical limitation. He plays a huge, wide, heavy 6 string bass. His fingers are short and stubby. You can always maximize what you've got.we all have different physical makeup, and it really doesn't matter.

Overall, get as much music in your head as possible. Be able to lay out anything you hear in your head on your instrument. What goes in comes out. Put a lot in, work on getting it out.
 
homerthinking_zps2fb6d53e.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyM
That sums up all these "how do I be really good, awesome, best ever bass player threads".

Was Duck Dunn really good? Could he play crazy modal jazz solos on a 6 string?

Does Duck = Jaco?
Does Jaco = Wooten?
Does Wooten = Jamerson?
Does Jamerson = Carol Kaye……..:whistle:


What is good?
 
I have been playing for 40 years and I never wanted to develop blazing solos. The VAST majority of bass solos...and drums solos are boring to anyone who is not a bass player or a drummer.

If you want to be a killer be a killer. If you want to play with people...groove.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JustEADG and Stumbo
I have been playing for 40 years and I never wanted to develop blazing solos. The VAST majority of bass solos...and drums solos are boring to anyone who is not a bass player or a drummer.

If you want to be a killer be a killer. If you want to play with people...groove.
Why can't you do both? Most of the best groovers I've ever heard have the most facility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Bonny
Learn music theory. In progress!

Learn to be a pro sight reader. Sight read classical.
Working on that, but I'm terrible at it.

Learn to sight sing. In progress
Those three skills would top the list of my suggestions as they all help each other. I guarantee that better theory will make sight reading and sight singing a lot easier. Theory makes everything easier.

Being able to sight read opens up a HUGE amount of opportunities for playing with very highly trained/skilled musos AND pretty easy money too.

Download free bass transcriptions of songs and practice sight reading those. You'll be expanding your song repertoire at the same time as boosting your reading skills.


I'll also add: know your fretboard, Get off TAB, & learn to play as many different styles of music as possible.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyM