• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How "Whiplash" changed my life.

twinjet

Moderator
Staff member
Gold Supporting Member
Sep 23, 2008
8,392
16,202
49
www.talkbass.com
For those who have seen the movie Whiplash, you know it's an intense flick. The musicianship is superb, the story is riveting and the language... harsh. For those who haven't, watch it.

For the past two years, I have been über focused on gear. I'd spent close to $2,000. Not much for the average TBer, but that's a lot to me. Of the gear I had gone through, almost all of it was an incurred loss.

Before you say it, just know this isn't so much another "No GAS" thread, as it is an inspirational thread. Watching Whiplash got me thinking. All the musicians in the movie are incredibly talented. How did they get there? Not by perusing pawn shops 3 days a week, I'm sure. Not by buying the latest and greatest instruments. Just hard, extensive practicing.

I'm big into jazz. It's my absolute favorite stuff to play. If I could actually make a successful living off of playing, I'd do it. That isn't going to happen (it's not a life goal), but I would still love to be an active circuit player in my town.

My biggest struggle as a bass player is and has been maintaining my tempo. Now, I don't allow tempo to significantly change, but I do know that I tend to speed up or slow down enough to fall a half-beat behind on occasion. In a live performance the change is usually unnoticeable, as I can cover it up with a fill. But sometimes, if the band slows down and I try to speed it up, I end up second-guessing the original tempo and if I'm right. That's when it becomes noticeable. The occasional syncopated solo from the drummer or pianist can really throw me off, as well. While watching Whiplash, this trend stuck out like a sore thumb while I counted in my head during drum solo scenes.

How the movie changed my life:

A few weeks ago, I had made a commitment to sticking with a single electric bass until April 2017. Watching the movie forced me to shift how I thought and approached bass. My gear-oriented thoughts have lingered on to learning, bettering myself as a bassist, expanding my repertoire and just making the best music I possibly could. Now, I play whenever I can. The movie has got me wanting to get out there and hustle. Yesterday I picked up my bass and hit two different jams to kickstart my night. I got out there, played some solid bass and left the jam with three less business cards than when I had gone in (I only carry three, maybe more now!).

For the foreseeable future, I will be making exactly 0 bass purchases as I strive to be the best I can be. What this means is daily practice. Reading about and applying technique, theory, ear training, sightreading, melodies, improvisation & rhythmic exercises and so much more. We have an endless ability to learn and my desire to do so is fuelled by that knowledge.

I may not be the next Jaco, but I am content knowing that over the next few years I will evolve as a player. I am a good bassist now who can hold his own, but I want to become a damned good bassist, and I want people to know that when I back someone up. Not for egotistical purposes, but so I can be known as a dependable player.

In conclusion:

Always strive to improve and make the best music you possibly can. I have pledged that to myself. The most inspirational part of the movie can be seen in this clip:

[Note: Explicit Language]


Thanks for reading.
 
Glad it inspired you.

Just don't make yourself UTTERLY MISERABLE like the students in that movie.

There is no fame or chops worth the crap hey put themselves through.
Agreed. They practice to the point of hating the music. One reason I chose not to pursue an education in it.
 
Last edited:
I think foregoing the gear quest and the clip from the movie are about two very different things. It's not like the gear wasn't telling you how great you were or how much you suck. You need people to do that and people, not gear, usually become the impetus for our next steps forward or backward. I do agree with the idea that it can be hurtful to praise someone for a mediocre effort, as it seems to be the idea in the clip, and if it wasn't for a real live person telling me honestly how much I sucked at one point, I probably never would have excelled. It became a driving force for improvement as I didn't want to hear it ever again, or at least not as much. I also agree that there is a fine line between inspiration and discouragement depending on the delivery, which was also a central point I derived from the clip.

So, nice clip, but it doesn't seem analogous to what you're saying is your impetus to get better...but what matters is that you're choosing to get better, and that's important. Good luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gregmon79
5188.gif
5186.gif
5185.gif


I agree, Twinjet..
 
That movie did the exact opposite to me. I've hardly touched any of my instruments since watching it.

Getting better so you won't get laughed at just doesn't appeal to me.

Then there was a bit of talk/typing on here about how it's all about vanity, & it's true.
Realizing I had some stuff for what appeared to be vanity, I sold them.

Now I have the bare minimum & I still don't touch my gear very often.
Maybe this is the final stage before I finally sell it all & just watch TV & play video games as a hobby.

OTOH, it's great that you were able to use the film as a motivation.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tommyc and twinjet
I think foregoing the gear quest and the clip from the movie are about two very different things. It's not like the gear wasn't telling you how great you were or how much you suck. You need people to do that and people, not gear, usually become the impetus for our next steps forward or backward. I do agree with the idea that it can be hurtful to praise someone for a mediocre effort, as it seems to be the idea in the clip, and if it wasn't for a real live person telling me honestly how much I sucked at one point, I probably never would have excelled. It became a driving force for improvement as I didn't want to hear it ever again, or at least not as much. I also agree that there is a fine line between inspiration and discouragement depending on the delivery, which was also a central point I derived from the clip.

So, nice clip, but it doesn't seem analogous to what you're saying is your impetus to get better...but what matters is that you're choosing to get better, and that's important. Good luck.
Thanks for the comment. I mostly used the clip to show the story of Parker and to illustrate the importance of effort and where it gets you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nixdad
I have a friend who is a trumpet player. He is by far the most dedicated musician I know. He finally made it into the LA studio scene and soon after he did all he could talk about was getting into some other line of work. The music business really turned him off. He still loves to play but now it's completely on his terms. If he even thinks a gig will be a pain he won't take it. I'm saying all this because for years I was inspired by this man only to see him practically stop playing because of the business. It's great to get good at your instrument but not at the cost of everything else. I think the movie shows this to some extent.
 
At the end of the movie I was hoping that the young drummer dude would jam a drumstick in that old farts left ear and keep pushing until it came out the right then grab the parts sticking out and twist his head off. What a horrible teacher and sorry excuse for a human being. I like the actor that played the teacher in those insurance company ads though.

"That's not my time. Again...That's not my time. Again...That's not my time."
 
That's good stuff... I need to motivate myself to move forward with bass. Maybe, as with the movie, I'll highlight what I can't do to see just how much I'm missing and start picking things off the (admittedly long) list... can't read quickly, hardly know scales and intervals, theory is pretty weak, etc.

"I SUCK!" he yelled, storming off to practice in his bedroom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twinjet
Any day a player goes from being gear-focused to music focused is good day.

Stop worrying about the gear. Start worrying about the music.
Exactly. My bass makes all the sounds I need and like. It's an eye pleaser. It's easy to play. No need to waste more time and money!

I'm excited about this journey because I'm not very good at much else, but the bass thing I have a pretty good hold on. I could always stand to improve, and so I shall! Onward!
 
I've been through many ups and downs with my chops, my gear, my focus, my opportunities. When my children were first born, I channeled a lot of energy into building an arsenal of basses. Now that my life has stabilized, I have noticed a natural focus on taking my chops to another level with the gear I've assembled and I peruse the classifieds much less.

Also: since I first noticed my bass slump, I have branched out into guitar for the first time and dusted off my drums, as well.