• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is a drum machine really necessary to learn bass?

Developing good time is absolutely essential. A drum machine is just one tool that can help with that.

When I taught bass, I always liked to have a drum set in the studio. It was out on loan and one of my guys came in for his regular lesson and was seriously bummed. If you're playing rock/pop/R&B or jazz, yeah, you should practice with drums. But that could mean real drummer, playing along with recordings, or even just a metronome as others have said.
 
I have 5 or 6 drum machines... never used any of them to practice bass. I don't even have a metronome; I either use the Google online metronome, or practice along with song recordings (I have the songs I play on a playlist, which I usually play in random order).

However, in the past couple of weeks I've been practicing using a looper with a cajon (with a mic) and other acoustic percussions (shakers, tambourine, darbuka), bass and piano. I feed everything through a cheap behringer mixer, and then to the looper. It's really cool to build a rhythm and then play the bass on top.
 
You don’t need one, but it’s a good tool to get your timing down and learn to play with different beats. It doesn’t have be to anything fancy. What comes with a Casio keyboard is enough.
 
Last edited:
Funny enough, I have very rarely use anything in my practices. I used a metronome very briefly when I first started playing and I occasionally will have a drum loop going on my looper. I don't require it to stay in time though. The beat is in my head. It does help however to have something but it's definitely not a must. The Beat Buddy is a cool little practice tool. Expensive but cool.
 
who said it's necessary?

it depends on the player, the goal of the player, the types of folks that you do or plan to play with, your own natural rhythm, your own ability to hear your own inaccuracies, and the style of music.

So many variables.

I have at times practice with a metronome, and at times with a drum machine. Depends on what I was trying to fix in my playing.

Biggest thing I have found to solve my playing issues if I want to be picky, is recording myself playing and then playing it back at a slower speed. Amazingly revealing. Playing along to a song (like to a track from a band I like) and recording it is super helpful, specially if I put my bass in left side and song in right, or whatever, then mix it accordingly, and also slow it down when needed.

musicians should be able to play metronomically as a basic skill, and yes drum machines are a good way to learn to do that.

But musicians mostly play with other musicians, or on their own, and that is often a situation where tempo and rhythm might NOT be metronomic, but will need to groove with other musicians, in which case you benefit from practicing playing with songs, with bands, with albums.... just as much as with a metronome or drum machine.
 
I just have a digital metronome that I can break out and turn on wherever I go. I imagine an app on my phone would have been just as useful, but I like the metronome because it seems to encourage me to mess with my guitars and basses rather than my phone which already gets enough attention.

That said, if you can just get a beat going in your head that can be enough--especially if you're coming from a place of playing guitar.

In my opinion, the biggest issue with people who seem to double is that guitar players turned bass players can be unnecessarily "busy" on the fingerboard. It's not always the case; rhythm guitar players tend to be better bass players (in general), but you hopefully get what I mean. Right hand technique (if you don't use a pick) is something that takes some time to develop as well.

I never thought much about the time keeping aspect of it--at least I never put much thought into where my clicks come from. *shrug*