• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is bassist-life possible without a Precision?

My first two basses were P clones, I never liked the tone. Then my third bass, a Pedulla Series II had a PJ set up and I only liked the sound with both pick ups or just the bridge pick up on. I'm not a big fan of the P tone, turns out I never was.

That's it right there. If you love classic P-bass tone (like I do) you've got to have a Precision (or two). But if that's not your tone, no reason to own one. (And if a studio producer insists on your using one, borrow one from a friend.)
 
You sound like a real open-minded guy. :rollno:

+1

I'm all for open mindedness and playing what you want to play, but I'm anti-P in the sense that it doesn't work for me where others may like it. But being a fusion player, I like modern tones. However, I've done my share of pop stuff and my Kubicki, Status and Spector basses have all fitted in nicely. Are you telling me that Bass Viking's Ken Smith puts you off him?
 
Nope...

basspic1.jpg
 
Some songs just sound better w/P-bass. Listen to early U2 songs like "With or without you" sound - great w/p-bass. Early Elvis Costello "Pump it up" & "Everyday I write the book." The "Queen" sound and many many others. There are other good basses as well, but the P bass has its sound. The P-bass will have a place in history for sure.