• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Just a curious question. What picks do you use?

These work well for uber-bright piano tone stainless roundwounds...
 

Attachments

  • wedgies.jpg
    wedgies.jpg
    430.4 KB · Views: 23
Carole Kaye said she used a hard guitar pick with flatwounds and mute. I think many other artists of that era used that combination too. I got a set of Mick’s picks : the green rubber ones and the felt ones. I like them with flatwounds. My problem with thin smooth plastic ones is I always drop them… so something with some grippy texture where it’s held and/or that is thicker helps. I do like the sound of a plastic pic on round wounds… that metallic grind kind of tone in some rock.
I have felt Micks picks as well they are thick and easy to grasp plus I sand the edges on some of them to give a softer attack.

Also various hard Dunlops and a metal pick as well which really gives a biting attack.
 
I used 0.75~1 mm nylon picks for a long time, and the best ones were Herco reissue picks or D'Addario Nylflex picks. Later I discovered 0.71~0.96 mm moulded polycarbonate picks from Winner by Alice, and I've been using them ever since. They have a bright, clear tone (why would I use a pick at all when I want a fingerstyle tone?), and glide through the strings more easily than regular Nylon picks.
 
Of course preferences will vary person to person. For me, after quite a bit of experimenting, I long ago settled on the big triangular Dunlop TORTEX .73mm (yellow) picks for bass. This is in the range of a medium thickness.
IMG_3913.jpeg


For reference, I also use Dunlop Tortex yellow picks with guitar, but in that case I go with the regular "Standard" size/shape ones (still .73mm thickness).

I used to use the slightly thicker but still in the medium range greens (.88mm) on both bass and guitar (again, big triangles for bass, "Standard" size/shape for guitar), and still will if an old one of those is all I have to hand, but I’m just more of a yellower, I guess. I completely avoid Heavies (for Dunlop Tortex, 1.0mm or 1.14mm) and Thins (.50mm or .60mm), but some people prefer one or the other of those. Accordingly, you should probably experiment a bit to find your own preferences. Still, going with something in the medium thickness range seems safe enough.

Meanwhile, my favorite in terms of tone (in particular, in relation to the attack) was some felt picks I bought, but those gradually fall apart and you end up with little particles everywhere, eventually making a real mess. I could see going with felt to record a particular song or songs where that sound and feel is needed (and then throwing them out), but otherwise, I’ll just stick with my good old Dunlop yellow Tortexers (despite liking playing with the felt ones [they’re the most finger-like in the sound of the note attack], due to the inevitable attendant mess if you make the mistake of keeping them around, my felt picks are long gone and I have no plans to replace them)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lo-E
Jim Dunlop Max-Grip Nylon Standard Pick .60MM has been my go to for bass and guitar lately. It's grippy enough to not move around much in my fingers, but not so grippy that I can't reposition the pick easily and quickly.

Sometimes I'll use a thicker or thinner pick for fun, but my workhorse continues to be that one.

71x74qgwMuL._AC_SL1500_smaller.jpg
 
I went to a music store, and they had about 50 different models in various strengths.
Giving each a squeeze, I bought about 25 of them to try out, quickly found that some shapes (triangle, overly large) don't work for me and that I prefer the medium strength of about 1.0mm. In my hands, a soft pick feels like all the give that needs to happen when the pick hits the sting happens in the pick.
With strong picks, all the give has to come out of my hand and with the medium ones, it comes from both places.

Knowing what to look for now, I tried a few of the medium strength medium sized picks, nearly ordered one of the Blue Chip brand, but settled on the Rombo Crisp picks.
guitar-pick-set-rombopicks-crisp-coloured_800x.webp
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lo-E