I'm quite sure the Fdeck has a 10 Mohm input impedance. If there was a substantial difference across the pre- amps you tested, then that could certainly explain the differences you heard. That's because they would load the pickup differently. If we're talking about the usual DB pickups, then going above 10 Mohm will not change things much and may have drawbacks.
+1 You wouldn't want to load a DB pickup higher than 10 Meg Ohms. The Headway EDB-2 (EDB-1) has a 20 Meg Ohm setting that's used for Violin not Double Bass. I experimented with that setting and found that it thinned out the sound.
Ric