Very disappointing experience with a Kala California 5 fretless over the weekend. First the background: I own a Kala California 4 fretless (early one, no serial number) and love it. It’s used for standard sets in my GB band. I primarily play 5 string and have been looking for one for many months based upon the added string and a little more fingerboard room in the scale length.
So I recently found a Kala 5 String fretless for sale. It appears to be about the same age as mine, but has a serial and the bridge (plastic piece) is brown instead of white. It has the plug and charge battery system. I took my bass along to the shop to compare them:
PROS
-Scale Length- definitely a step in the right direction. It made finding the right fretless note easier and the neck was a bit beefier, feeling a little less like a toy.
CONS
-Output- immediately I was suspicious by the level the amp was set at to get a good volume. When I plugged my 4 string in I was immediately rattling the walls. It was at least twice as loud. I charged the 5 string bass and inspected the interior. There was nothing obvious to correct the issue. For the record, it had the same strings. In addition, the tone pots seemed to have a lesser impact on the overall tone.
-Balance- terrible neck dive, with and without a strap. The body had not been modified to offset the change in scale, including the length of the upper horn. If you’re not hugging the bass while playing it then it feels like it's trying to run away from you. Your left hand ends up supporting the bass rather than remaining agile.
-Action- despite the bridge being set the same as my own bass, the action was very high. The longer neck had a bit of curve to it and no truss rod. Fretting past the 10th fret became a chore.
Needless to say, I did not buy the bass - despite being a great price and an hour+ drive. I have not given up on the idea of finding one, but encourage all to try one out before purchasing. The drop in overall tone and playability was rather shocking, despite the bass being in excellent condition.
