Okay here I go. Everything here is I believe medium gauge in that I did not get the thicker gauge strings in that I would need to file down my nut.
GHS discontinued Black Tapes - these sounded lifeless to my ears, they were very thumpy and very similar to an upright bass tone in certain respects but the lifeless tone did not do it for me. I used to play Labella deep talkin flats which are pretty dark and these were even more dark to my ears. These were the farthest from rounds.
Daddarrio Black Tapes - After the coppers these are my second favorite tapewound. They are plenty deep and punchy and they feel pretty good too. Not quite bright enough for what I wanted and like all the black tapes the pick click noise was too much - although some picks did not have as much of that noise but still I prefer the coppers here. You can even slap on these tapes and it sounds decent but of course not as good as rounds for slapping IMO
Labella Black Tapes - The brightest of the black tapes I tried but did not quite have the same low end and punch as the daddarrio black tapes.
Labella Golds - did not work for me at all. Noticable loss of low end and punch and did not seem as good of a tone as the coppers. These were however my first pair of tapes and they felt amazing on my fingers and the slides, bends, trills, stings all felt like butter. So these strings started me on my tapewound string hunt.
Labella Whites - similiar to the golds in almost every way described above.
Labella Coppers - as mentioned my favorite string by far period. Coppers sound the most like rounds of all these tapes and feel as good as the golds.
In terms of tension I would say all these tapes had pretty low tension but none felt "floppy" to me. As mentioned I did not try any of the higher gauge strings since I did not want to file my nut and all that stuff and those thicker gauge strings will have more tension for sure. I personally love the lower tension and smooth feel of all these tapes but i would say the golds and the coppers felt the best in terms of smooth and comfort. But as mentioned the golds did not have a good tone IMO.
Hope that helps.
GHS discontinued Black Tapes - these sounded lifeless to my ears, they were very thumpy and very similar to an upright bass tone in certain respects but the lifeless tone did not do it for me. I used to play Labella deep talkin flats which are pretty dark and these were even more dark to my ears. These were the farthest from rounds.
Daddarrio Black Tapes - After the coppers these are my second favorite tapewound. They are plenty deep and punchy and they feel pretty good too. Not quite bright enough for what I wanted and like all the black tapes the pick click noise was too much - although some picks did not have as much of that noise but still I prefer the coppers here. You can even slap on these tapes and it sounds decent but of course not as good as rounds for slapping IMO
Labella Black Tapes - The brightest of the black tapes I tried but did not quite have the same low end and punch as the daddarrio black tapes.
Labella Golds - did not work for me at all. Noticable loss of low end and punch and did not seem as good of a tone as the coppers. These were however my first pair of tapes and they felt amazing on my fingers and the slides, bends, trills, stings all felt like butter. So these strings started me on my tapewound string hunt.
Labella Whites - similiar to the golds in almost every way described above.
Labella Coppers - as mentioned my favorite string by far period. Coppers sound the most like rounds of all these tapes and feel as good as the golds.
In terms of tension I would say all these tapes had pretty low tension but none felt "floppy" to me. As mentioned I did not try any of the higher gauge strings since I did not want to file my nut and all that stuff and those thicker gauge strings will have more tension for sure. I personally love the lower tension and smooth feel of all these tapes but i would say the golds and the coppers felt the best in terms of smooth and comfort. But as mentioned the golds did not have a good tone IMO.
Hope that helps.