• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Limiter for studio use

project_c

project_c

May 8, 2008
1,592
1,870
London, UK
#1
I'm looking for a limiter pedal to keep my gain from going into the red when I dig in when recording in the studio. I already have a compressor (Opto compulator) but I find that it's not the best tool for taming volume spikes, and I don't necessarily want to compress the signal as much as just limit the maximum volume so it doesn't clip.

I've read good and bad things about the Boss LMB-3 and I don't really need the 'enhance' feature, I really just want to be able to dig in for certain notes / phrases without sending my signal into the red. (Please don't suggest lowering the signal level, it is already relatively low - it only peaks when I really dig in and snap / pop a note).

Any good suggestions for a pedal that can do this well, and without much signal degradation?
 
#3
icecycle66 said:
I really love m7y Carl Martin Limiter/Compressor.

The LED that shows how much compression/limiting is happening is a great touch.
Click to expand...

This looks like a great pedal, but it seems to be primarily a compressor - I really only want to limit the loudest peaks of my signal, if at all possible, without squashing everything else. I'm not even sure if that is possible in a pedal form. (I know it can be done in a DAW, but that's no good to me if the recorded signal is already clipped).
 
#7
If it doesn't have to be a pedal a used dbx 160 or 166 is great
For that matter, the Behringer copies sound just fine and I couldn't sell a rack of them for $50 ea.
 
#9
You might want to check out the Demeter Compulator.

If you aren't already familiar with them, Bongomania's compressor and limiter reviews are very well documented and informative:

http://www.ovnilab.com/

From "My Top Pics" page for limiters: the Rane DC24, Valley People Dynamite, Aphex 661/651, MXR M87 Bass Comp, Maxon CP9 Pro+, Pigtronix Philosopher, Alesis MicroLimiter, Guyatone BL2, Boss LMB-3, various Joemeek models, Markbass, Demeter Compulator, FEA Comp-Limiter and DE-CL, Menatone J.A.C, Ashly DPX/CLX/CL series, Aguilar TLC, and Symetrix 501 all do a pretty good job of cleanly limiting big signal peaks.
 
#10
Depends on what You're looking for, color or function, but since You said limiting and recording so I'd recommend an Aphex 651 Expressor.
I've used a few different floor compressors at times but I have the Aphex in My studio rig, it does really well at controlling peaks and is pretty darn transparent at normal settings.
They can be had used for a pretty good price.
I'm sure Bongo has a review,
Good Luck
 
#12
Definitely check out the Daring Audio Phat Beam. Separate limiting and compression, unlimited headroom (and that's IME of using other pedals that made that claim and fell short) and studio-quality controls (TONS of tweakability) in a 9V, average-sized pedal.
 
#13
As mentioned before, no really need for a limiter if you lower the gain just not to clip the input, and don´t worry about signal being to low either, unless you record on tape (real tape). You can limit later in the mix and with more precision.

If in the studio, I´m sure the studio has some good limiters and not a pedal that in most casses is less efficient.
 
#14
+1 to setting your level at your most aggressive playing. Generally I find it better to do the most to keep as much stuff off my signal chain while recording...a healthy signal is key too, so if you already have comp on and your just clipping occasionally then just turning down a bit should be way more then fine.

99% of the time I get the players most aggressive level at around the 3/4 point on the meter. And that usually gives me plenty of room in both directions.
 
#15
project_c said:
thanks for the replies! already own the compulator, and while its an excellent compressor, it's not that great for cutting peaks without squishing everything else. will check out all the others though and see what happens.
Click to expand...

The big problem with the Compulator in this application is its lack of any visual meter or really usable input-level control. You're absolutely right that it will squash everything, if the signal you feed it is stronger than a typical passive Fender.
 
#17
Emibass said:
As mentioned before, no really need for a limiter if you lower the gain just not to clip the input, and don´t worry about signal being to low either, unless you record on tape (real tape). You can limit later in the mix and with more precision.
Click to expand...

+1 (actually, +1000) When recording digitally, you can set your level low enough to just allow the noise of your signal chain (without you playing) to register on your recording device. That will maximize the dynamic range available to you for your playing. And yes, it may appear that during recording the signal is low and weak, but as noted above, that can be raised during mixing.

And by "registering" I mean the noise floor can be seen in the waveform when you have zoomed in on waveform. Don't confuse this with registering on whatever level meters you have available because your meters may not show the entire range you are recording. For example, a 24-bit recording device is capable of recording down to about -120 db. Your meters may be showing a range of only -60 db to 0 db. If you have control over the range shown by your recording device meters, increase the range to where you can see the noise floor.

The same goes for recording vocals, guitars, and everything else.
 
#18
bongomania said:
The big problem with the Compulator in this application is its lack of any visual meter or really usable input-level control. You're absolutely right that it will squash everything, if the signal you feed it is stronger than a typical passive Fender.
Click to expand...

Ironically, my passive P-bass puts out a much stronger signal than any of my active basses.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back